Showing posts with label Penn State. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Penn State. Show all posts

Saturday, March 14, 2009

Truly Bizarre Games Probably Lock Up A 1 Seed For Pitt

After Pitt's humbling loss to WVU, I postulated that there was a definite chance that the Panthers' previously "locked up" number 1 seed might not be so locked up after all if certain events were to transpire.

So much for that.

Basically every other contender for a 1 seed besides Louisville and Memphis (who doesn't count because they play their games against Little Sisters of the Poor) has been upset in the past few days, to the point that things have essentially been reset to where they were at the beginning of the week. And that of course means that the Panthers are just about locked in a top seed.

It may not be exactly how I imagined this week going, and certainly there are still kinks to be a bit worried about as the Panthers approach the Big Dance, but after watching the quintet of Kansas, Oklahoma, North Carolina, Connecticut and Michigan State all match Pitt's losing effort, we figure to be celebrating the first number 1 seed in school history tomorrow night.

Of course, after a few moments of talking about it being cool to be a 1 seed, it is right back to work and back to focusing on the task at hand, which of course is making a legit run at the national championship and breaking through the Sweet 16 barrier that has toyed with our emotions the past several seasons.

On an semi-related note: It would be kinda cool to see Duquesne win tonight, right? Personally I have absolutely nothing against the Dukes and have a number of friends that go there and who weren't even aware Duquesne still had a basketball program until the past couple days. In all seriousness, though, it would be especially cool because a win would mean that (potentially) all the main local teams would be dancing this year. Our Panthers are obviously in, probably as a 1 seed. Bobby Mo wrapped up the NEC title a few days ago and are being projected around a 14 or so. The Dukes, if they win, would probably fall around a 12 or 13. West Virginia is a lock for an at-large and I'd venture a guess that they'll be around a 6 seed or so. And Penn State currently resides on the bubble of the at-large teams, but they have at least a decent chance to get in and would likely get either an 11 or 12 seed.

It'd be cool to see which ones of the local squads enjoy the most success. I personally am hoping that it happens.

Thursday, March 12, 2009

What Would Have Happened If Penn State Had Joined The Big East?

In case you missed it, Mike Tranghese conducted an interview in which he talked extremely candidly about Penn State's long-rumored bid to join the Big East that was shot down in 1982.

Naturally, that got me to thinking, how exactly would the sports landscape look nowadays if the Big East had gotten 1 more positive vote for PSU and gone on their little envoy to State College and the Nitts had accepted? Tranghese certainly has a fun little theory:

"The whole face of college athletics would be changed now. If we had taken Penn State in 1982, we may still have football independents. The idea wasn’t to take Penn State and start a football league. It was to give Penn State a place. And then they would have been aligned with Syracuse and Boston College. We probably would have brought Pitt in, too, and the four of them probably would have agreed to play and continue as independents. I think the whole face of college football would have changed. I don’t think Florida State would have moved and Miami would have moved. All of it came about when Penn State made the decision to go to the Big Ten."

Hmm...interesting thought by Mike, but I don't fully buy that at all. I still think that football would have gone to a heavy emphasis on conferences, and that while Penn State was certainly an important domino to fall in that chain reaction in 1989, I don't think them joining a power basketball conference like the Big East would have prevented them, and others, from looking to line up with football conferences around that same time period.

What many people around my age or even a little older may not know or really remember is that Penn State was in the A-10 for b-ball prior to leaving for the Big Ten. That wasn't really enough of a support for them, which is why they were so keen to the Big Ten's overtures. I think the Big East would have given them more support, though, had they joined.

There is also the little matter about Joe Paterno's failed All-Eastern sports league or whatever the hell that was supposed to be called. That infamously failed around the same time the Big East was deciding not to extend an invite to Penn State in '82. To me this is truely bizarre for the Big East, but whatever. Maybe they were worried about not having a natural partner for Penn State, but adding the rival Pitt Panthers at the same time seems to make quite a bit of sense to me. And, it is my complete and total guesswork belief that had Penn State joined, JoePa would have eventually come to think of the Big East as the potential substitute for the All Eastern Sports League that he wanted, and maybe he would have helped to spearhead a Big East Football Conference. After all, Syracuse, Boston College and Pitt would have all been in the Big East at that time, and others like Miami, Temple, Rutgers and Virginia Tech could probably have been easily swayed to join up for all sports if the bonus was a football conference, that is if you believe Paterno's faith in the others schools lining up for his conference, and I do believe him.

While I respect his opinion, I do disagree with Trangehese's assessment that we would still have major programs like Penn State, Florida State and Miami still as independents. I believe the almighty dollar would have won out eventually regardless of Penn State being the first important domino to fall or not. Because really, the conferences as a collective unit clearly had more power than the individual programs at this time, with just one exception: Notre Dame. The Irish of course are still independent and making a pile of money because of it, but I don't buy for a second that any other school could pull this off. I respect the huge following that PSU, FSU and Miami have built up, but they pale in comparison to the total numbers and the geographic reach of the Irish. Eventually these three would have realized they were better off joining a football conference than going it alone.

So clearly there would have been some sort of alternate timeline for the Big East. If I were to predict I think it would have looked something like this (keep in mind I'm dealing only on what the basketball and football versions of the conference would have looked like, the other sports, I could really care less about):

1979: Big East is founded by UConn, Georgetown, Providence, Seton Hall, St. John's, Syracuse and Boston College for basketball. No football conference.

1980: Villanova joins for basketball. 8 Teams now in the basketball league.

1982: Pitt and Penn State join for basketball. This is where the alternate "Watchmen-style" universe starts up.

1987: I believe Paterno would have put aside the grudge about the All-Eastern Sports League in order to create the Big East football conference, because well, it would have been basically the same thing. I even think he would have been the leader for this cause. And so I think the Big East Conference gets a football league, 4 years earlier than they did in reality, because of JoePa and his impressive pull. Paterno would have worked to assemble some of the same teams from his original conference. Obviously Pitt, Penn State, Syracuse and Boston College would have been in as they were when the league initially formed. The league would have then added Rutgers and West Virginia from Paterno's original plan for sure. From there we require some guesswork, as 6 teams probably wouldn't have been enough. There is a chance UConn could have joined in 87. Turns out they were part of Paterno's football plan in 82. I'm not sure what the deal with them was and why they were I-AA for so long, but I'm going to assume that they wouldn't have been able to join. So we now look at the independents. I think Virginia Tech and Temple are fair bets to be in for jumping to the Big East, and the other target would have been Miami. I'm going to say that the Hurricanes stay stingy and don't yet join. I think the new schools start out as football-only, much like how things worked in 91. So now we have a conference that shakes out like this:
Basketball: UConn, Georgetown, Providence, Seton Hall, St. John's, Syracuse, Boston College, Villanova, Pitt, Penn State
Football: Pitt, Penn State, Syracuse, Boston College, West Virginia, Rutgers, Temple, Virginia Tech
That's a pretty solid conference, no? Even if it is a little bit weird.

1991: This is about when West Virginia, Rutgers and Virginia Tech start demanding their entry into basketball and everything else. Temple and VT stay A-10 for whatever reason in basketball, as that was how they both rolled for several years. Never could really figure that one out. So then we have 6 schools that are full-fledged all-everything members (Penn State, Pitt, Syracuse, Boston College, West Virginia and Rutgers), 6 schools that are non-football members (UConn, Georgetown, Providence, Seton Hall, St. John's and Villanova) and 2 schools that are non-basketball members (Virginia Tech and Temple). 14 institutions in all, with 8 in football and 12 in basketball. Seems like great numbers all-around

1993: This is when I think Miami joins up for football, one year later than they did in reality. Not entirely sure why I picked it like this, but it seemed about right. Like I said earlier, it makes sense that maybe it takes a little longer for some of the dominos to fall to convince the final football independents not named Notre Dame to join up with conferences, and with the Big East already established in football, the Canes might have to wait another year or two. This is my reality, though, so I am sticking with '92. Seems to make some sense. They also join up in all sports immediately. Here's how things look:
Football (9 Schools): Miami, Pitt, Penn State, Syracuse, Boston College, Virginia Tech, West Virginia, Rutgers and Temple
Basketball (13 Schools): Miami, Pitt, Penn State, Syracuse, Boston College, West Virginia, Rutgers, Providence, Seton Hall, Georgetown, Villanova, UConn and St. John's

1995: I don't think a 13 school basketball league would have been a big hit for long. The guess here is that the Big East not only gives Notre Dame the non-basketball bid that they got in real life, but that Virginia Tech and Temple are both granted the complete membership both sought around this time.
Football (9 Schools): Miami, Pitt, Penn State, Syracuse, Boston College, Virginia Tech, West Virginia, Rutgers and Temple
Basketball (16 Schools): Virginia Tech, Temple, Notre Dame, Miami, Pitt, Penn State, Syracuse, Boston College, West Virginia, Rutgers, Providence, Seton Hall, Georgetown, Villanova, UConn and St. John's
That's right folks, the 16 team behemoth comes a decade earlier than it did in real life. Unwieldy much? This is where the real interesting stuff starts to hit the fan.

2001: I have felt since the moment the Big East started play with 16 basketball teams that a split was inevitable between the football and non-football schools, and it almost occurred even before the 16 team conference in 2004/2005. I think it occurs around 2001 in this alternate universe after 6 years of a 16 team basketball league. Here's how the battleground would have been drawn just on the schools that were previously in the conference:
Football/ Basketball Conference (9 Members): Miami, Pitt, Penn State, Syracuse, Boston College, Virginia Tech, West Virginia, Rutgers, Temple
Basketball Only Conference (7 Members): Notre Dame, Providence, Seton Hall, Georgetown, Villanova, UConn and St. John's

But let's be honest, that isn't enough teams. At least for the basketball only conference that would likely be the one to retain the "Big East" moniker. As for the new conference, I'm just going to give it a bland name like the All-Eastern Sports League (sound familiar?). I'm not creative enough for anything more than that. So then the new Big East conference needs at least another member or two. I think this is when the C-USA raid occurs at Notre Dame's urging and that they swoop in and snag DePaul and Marquette who would fit absolutely perfectly. They also might look at some A-10 schools like Xavier, Dayton and Duquesne to even things out between ND and the eastern seaboard teams. For now, I will stick with them just taking Xavier as well for an even 10 teams. I think the Eastern Conference stays put at 9 schools. For now. So now here's what it looks like:
All-Eastern Sports League: Miami, Pitt, Penn State, Syracuse, Boston College, Virginia Tech, West Virginia, Rutgers, Temple
Big East: Marquette, DePaul, Xavier, Notre Dame, Providence, Seton Hall, Georgetown, Villanova, UConn and St. John's

2004: This is when the raid occurred between the Big East and the ACC. I don't think that happens now, as with Penn State in tow Miami should be happier at the level of competition and not looking to leave, and the ACC would have to be a bit afraid of us right now, as that is clearly the superior conference. If anything we think about raiding the ACC, but we'll get to that. Nothing actually happens in this season.

2005: In the All-Eastern Sports League, pathetic Temple is still given the boot and UConn leaves the Big East for the Eastern Conference so that they can play football. I also think the conference wants to add a 10th team so that there isn't an awkward bye every week, and that they still go ahead and raid Louisville from Conference USA, as the Ville is a legit school and probably should have been playing with the big boys a long time ago. This also gives a bit of a credibility bump to the All-Eastern Sports League in basketball. Here's what that new conference looks like:
All-Eastern Sports League (10 Teams): Miami, Pitt, Penn State, Syracuse, Boston College, Virginia Tech, West Virginia, Rutgers, UConn, Louisville
Big East (9 Teams): Marquette, DePaul, Xavier, Notre Dame, Providence, Seton Hall, Georgetown, Villanova, and St. John's

2006: Both conferences raid and expand. The All-Eastern Sports League does to the ACC what the ACC did to us in real life. Miami wants a mate for the south and lures away Florida State and VT can't support anything unless their mates Virginia are included, so the new league gets to 12 teams. I think this is a definite possibility, as the almighty dollar from the title game is so very important (even if the ACC title game is a trainwreck in real life) and the new conference looks like this:
All-Eastern Sports League: (12 Teams): Miami, Pitt, Penn State, Syracuse, Boston College, Virginia Tech, West Virginia, Rutgers, UConn, Louisville, Virginia, Florida State
We'd have to break this up somehow, so here's my guess:
North: Pitt, Penn State, Syracuse, Boston College, Rutgers, UConn
South: Miami, Virginia, Virginia Tech, Florida State, West Virginia, Louisville

In addition, the Big East goes and snatches up St. Joseph's to add and give it 10 teams again and pair them up with fellow Philly schools Nova and Temple:
Big East (10 Teams): Marquette, DePaul, Xavier, Notre Dame, Providence, Seton Hall, Georgetown, Villanova, St. John's, St. Joseph's

And that is the final maneuver I see being made. Just like in reality, the Big East is in constant flux over the last 20 years in my alternate universe. Sorry if this was confusing or stupid or if you skimmed this beast and were thrown off by my referring to the football/ basketball conference as the All-Eastern Sports League late in the column after the split. That's just a working name. It's late and I had no creative juices flowing and things kinda ran together a bit.

Still, I think it would be tough to deny a lot of the stuff I stated here would have been plausible if we had just been smart and invited Penn State in and JoePa still had the passion for an all-football conference. He would've been perfect to lead the charge and his school could have given the Big East more credibility, and couple with Miami would have given us two big time powerhouses in the mid-90s and maybe even prevented an ACC raid. I may not be a Penn State fan, but there is no denying their clout and potential impact. Sigh. If only.

Thursday, February 19, 2009

Penn State beats Illinois 38-33 in Football Game. Oh wait...

I normally exclude Penn State from this blog for any number of reasons, but mainly: 1) I'm a Pitt student and lifetime fan so its hard for me to really feel like covering another school, especially a "rival" (even though we aren't rivals!) and 2) Penn State is not in Pittsburgh.

Typically the only time I cover Penn State is if it is because I have a reason to embarass them. This occasion is no different. Before I go any further I'd just like to dedicate this any of my friends at PSU who poked fun at Big East Football. This is for you...

Honest to goodness, the final score of Penn State/ Illinois (with Illinois supposedly being a Top 25 team and Penn State supposedly being a bubble tourney team) was 38-33 last night. Right now you are thinking to yourself, "That's a misprint" or "I think he means that's the score of the Penn State/ Illinois football game this past season." You would be incorrect. Now you are probably opening up a new tab on your browser and getting ready to scan ESPN's scoreboard. Here let me save you the trouble.

Can you imagine how atrocious that game must have been? James Naismith would've torn down that peach basket and gone back to the drawing board if he knew this was the result. I can tell even the PSU fans are embarassed and they won. When PSU stunned Sparty a few weeks ago I got not less than 5 texts/ IMs/ phone calls from Penn State fans fired up that their team was on the way back and that Penn State's b-ball program was now on a national level, same as Pitt. Yesterday? I didn't hear a peep. I didn't even know the game had happened until the SportsCenter anchors were making fun of it.

I mean how can anyone take that conference seriously? You can't! How many points would Pitt beat these teams by? 50? 100? In fact, you could combine these two teams and Pitt would win by 20. At least. And that's with Jamie Dixon putting Ryan Tiesi and Tim Frye and Gary "The Human Foul" McGhee in for the last 2 minutes.

You know what the score of the Penn State- Illinois football game was? 38-24 Penn State. Their football team scored as many points as the basketball team! In one 20-minute stretch Penn State was 3/26 shooting. And they won. I'm not entirely convinced either one of these teams would score a point if they played UConn or Pitt. I'm seriously not.

Okay, that's all for me. Don't worry, I'm sure I'll slip a joke about this excuse for a basketball game into my next 20 posts.

Friday, January 9, 2009

My College Football Playoff

So as you may remember, a few weeks back I put together my own version of a college football playoff. Also, here are the rules for this playoff. And so, with last night concluding the 2008 college football bowl season, I figured I'd go back and take a stab at how these playoffs would play out.

First Round
Texas vs. Ohio State at Tampa Bay December 20 Noon
This game actually happened, so we have something to base it on, and it was no real surprise to see what happened on the field in the Fiesta Bowl. With Texas having even more to play for than they did in real life, I think they more than take care of business against the Buckeyes and advance onward to the second round. Texas 34 Ohio State 17

Penn State vs. Boise State at Houston December 20 6:00
Yeah Penn State didn't show up at all in the Rose Bowl, but that was against the mighty USC Trojans. This game is against a Boise State squad that dropped the Poinsettia Bowl to TCU. Don't get me wrong, I commend the Broncos for their excellent season, but this team can't quite play with the big boys. Penn State 34 Boise State 17

Cincinnati vs. Texas Tech at Orlando December 20 3:00
Both these squads kind of laid an egg in their bowl games. However, as much as I would love to see Cincinnati get a W to represent the Big East, I think Texas Tech lacked some serious motivation in that loss to Ole Miss and was probably disappointed by the Cotton Bowl berth when they felt they deserved a shot at the championship. There's no question that this game would probably be similarly high-scoring because of the way Tech plays. Texas Tech 45 Cincinnati 31

Virginia Tech vs. Alabama at San Diego December 20 9:00
After watching Tech's bowl game I think this one would be a much better game than I originally would have thought. VT was at its finest playing good-old-fashioned Beamer Ball, and Alabama's "offense" would have ensured that this one remained pretty close. Still, despite the results in their respective bowl games, I think Alabama is too much for Virginia Tech. Alabama 17 Virginia Tech 14

Second Round
Oklahoma vs. Alabama at New Orleans December 27 3:00
Although Oklahoma had issues with the SEC Champ Gators in the Natty, the near-SEC-champs aren't nearly the same matchup nightmare for the Sooners. Sam Bradford proves he is Heisman-worthy, and does to the Tide what Utah did in the Sugar Bowl. Oklahoma 48 Alabama 17

Florida vs. Texas Tech at Atlanta December 27 Noon
Tim Tebow finally gets into action and does not disappoint. Tech had quite the disaster trying to defend the Ole Miss offense, and is unbelievably impotent in trying to stop the Heisman trophy winning legend. Florida's D is able to hold up reasonably well to the Tech offense. Florida 48 Texas Tech 21

USC vs. Penn State at Dallas December 27 6:00
We've already seen how this matchup plays out, and with the mighty Trojans hungry for a national championship. Southern Cal blows the doors off of Penn State in our third straight blowout of the day. USC 45 Penn State 21

Utah vs. Texas at San Francisco December 27 9:00
Utah is a much, much better team than I would have ever imagined. They absolutely took Alabama apart. I think this would be a spectacular game, and if Utah can play like they did in that Bama game, we'd finally have ourselves a good quarterfinal matchup. Despite Colt McCoy's big season and the Longhorns' belief that they deserve a shot at the title, I'm a believer in the Utes getting at least one playoff win. Utah 34 Texas 31

Semi-finals

Oklahoma vs. Utah at Pasadena
Much like the Texas-Utah game, this game suddenly got a lot more interesting once we saw just how good Utah really is. While the Sooners weren't able to come away with a W against Florida in the title game, playing against Utah would be a very different story. I think Utah played the game of their season in the win over Alabama and would do similarly against Texas. After that win, though, I'm hard-pressed to imagine them putting together a second straight dominant performance like that. Oklahoma 37 Utah 28

Florida vs. USC at Phoenix
Now this is the game that everyone is clamoring to see this morning. The speedy, mighty Trojans of the west taking on the dominant, hard-hitting, fast, talented Gators of the east. This one would be an epic game. The Trojans have more speed across the board at the skill positions I think, but the one thing they don't have: Tim Tebow. Florida 35 USC 28

National Championship Game
Oklahoma vs. Florida
So after all this work, after eliminating 10 teams in 10 games and going through the pains of playing at all these different locations and including anyone with a reasonable shot at the title...it turns out that the title game is the same thing that the BCS gave us. So maybe there is something to this BCS thing. Still, don't we all feel a little bit better knowing that everyone was included? I thought so. Florida 24 Oklahoma 14

Tuesday, December 30, 2008

Pitt- Oregon State Sun Bowl Preview

This is almost certainly the final post of the year for us here at Three River Sports, as tomorrow will be filled with watching Pitt athletic teams and drinking, and no one wants a half-drunk posting following the Pitt-OSU game, so have a Happy New Year and be safe out there kids.

But before I get to the subject of this little column, I NEEDED to link to this little story in the Trib regarding our beloved tailback LeSean McCoy who is showing some serious feistiness in wanting to get the old Pitt-Penn State rivalry resumed. Clearly the Pitt players, many of whom have high school friends at the State College, enjoy having some fun with it and want to play, but until that guy from Tales From The Crypt retires as the PSU Head Coach, the rivalry is dead, unfortunately.
Anyway, let's get to this thing, with some of the critical things to watch for in this ball game:
-As always, the Panthers are likely to only go as far as the legs of LeSean McCoy will take them. Expect McCoy to get the ball early and often, and surely Oregon State's defense is going to try to do everything humanly possible to stop McCoy short of putting 11 in the box. The Beavers would love for Pitt to have to use Bill Stull to beat them.

-Of course, Jonathan Baldwin will likely get a few shots downfield early in the game to try and keep the Beavers D honest. If Stull can complete even one of those to the scary athletic wide receiver it could change everything. I'm sure the Beavers have seen the number of missed downfield passes, and thus won't truly commit to stopping it until the Panthers prove that it can work.

-Rashaad Duncan started yapping a couple days ago, and now the Oregon State O-Line has heard it and is using it for bulletin board material. I'm not a big fan of these kinds of tactics, so I certainly could have done without all that, but let's just hope Rashaad lives up to his claims. Pitt's D-Line sets the tone for the D, and lets hope that tone is more like the one set in the Iowa and WVU games and less like the Cincy or Rutgers games.

-With Jacquizz Rodgers expected to miss the Sun Bowl, its pretty apparent that Oregon State is going to have to rely more heavily on their passing game. Its pretty clear that the Beavers aren't too comfortable throwing the ball a lot, though, because although QB Lyle Moevao has three 300 yard passing games, they were all in losses. Still, the Beavers new starting running back Ryan McCants is a freshman with 79 career carries. I expect the Panthers D-Line to mostly shut him down and force OSU to the air.

-Aaron Berry, Jovanni Chappel, Dom DeCicco, and the rest of the Pitt secondary will have their work cut out for them if this is the case. OSU has two very good receivers even with the brothers Rodgers sitting on the sidelines. Neither Sammie Stroughter or Shane Morales are the tall downfield threats that have given the Panthers fits, but they are both better than any corner the Panthers can throw at them.

-One thing I didn't mention earlier about in regards to Pitt's passing game: Oregon State has a very good secondary that is likely to give our resident head-scratcher Bill Stull some serious fits. Brandon Hughes and Greg Laybourn were both all Pac-10 players and their other two DB's were honorable mention on the conference teams, a pretty scary thought considering the fragile confidence of Stull.

-While Oregon State has some good return men, their special teams, especially on field goals, have been mostly mediocre this season, and I fully expect to see Wanny bring the house with Romeous, Taglianetti, and the rest of the special teams demons to try to get some blocks. Few teams in the country are as good as the Panthers at blocking punts and kicks, and that could be a gamebreaker for the Panthers.

-The Beavers also have a solid D-Line, so I will be interested to see how well the Panthers O-Line, which has really REALLY come on strong at the end of this season, will fair against them. This is one of the more underrated aspects to Pitt's success this season, in my mind. Remember how many questions there were at the beginning of the season regarding this O-Line? Well Jason Pinkston and Joe Thomas have morphed into very promising tackle prospects, John Malecki has turned into a nasty guard, CJ Davis has been spectacular, and Dom Williams has been solid in relief.

The Bottom Line
I think the Panthers strike early with Shady, and the Beavers are unable to respond to a few quick scores without their beloved 'Quizz Rodgers leading the way on offense. McCoy goes off for well over 100 yards, Stull puts in a solid effort, and the Pitt D does a nice job holding what's left of the OSU offense in check. Panthers 31-20

Friday, December 12, 2008

The Bowl Poll Picks

It is indeed the most wonderful time of the year! Just to be clear, I'm not talking about Christmas or any other Hallmark-ed up Holiday, I'm talking about the one December holiday season that the card companies haven't picked up on: Bowl Season! Sure, I've made my displeasure with College Football's lack of a playoff system very well known on this site, but it turns out I'm quite good at talking out of both sides of my mouth, because there are few things that put a hop in my step as much as the college football bowl season. And since I am in 2 bowl polls, I figured I would give a rundown of my thought process for each of the 33 completely meaningless games and 1 meaningful game that start next Saturday and finish up Thursday January 8th. Let's get to it...
EagleBank Bowl
Wake Forest vs. Navy
Few things say the start of bowl season liked the historic EagleBank Bowl played in... (Googling "EagleBank Bowl location)...Washington D.C.?!? Really? Who decided it was a good idea to have an outdoor bowl game in December in D.C.? Anyway, this one is Wake Forest vs. Navy. Wake is a sneaky good ACC team, and I watched the Midshipmen get taken apart by my Panthers. The pick here is Wake Forest.

New Mexico Bowl
Colorado State vs. Fresno State
Two squads that were stuck in the middle of the best of the lower conferences doesn't exactly make you want to program the old TiVo does it? I'm leaning toward Colorado State simply because the Mountain West was a better conference than the WAC, and really that's my best reason.

Magicjack St. Petersburg Bowl
South Florida vs. Memphis
I was all fired up this morning when I came across a commercial for Magicjack. I watched the commercial and must say, this is probably the only year that product sponsors a bowl game. Anyway, this game will probably be South Florida heavy even though the Bulls were a god-awful team down the stretch because it's practically played in the Bulls backyard. So with that in mind, I will take the free-falling South Florida squad even though I think they are a mess of a team right now.

Pioneer Las Vegas Bowl
BYU vs. Arizona
This is a pretty good BYU squad that basically runs Las Vegas every December (they've been here 4 years in a row now!) against a mediocre Pac-10 team that is probably just happy to have gotten into a half-decent bowl after a tough finish to the season. I'll take BYU.

R+L Carriers New Orleans Bowl
Southern Miss vs. Troy
10 Syllables is too many for a bowl game to have, although just wait til I get to the next bowl down. Anyway, Southern Miss is a mediocre team in a below-average conference while Troy is the best team in the worst conference. I wonder if that's how this game will be advertised. Probably not. Sun Belt teams are barely Division I-A, so give me Southern Miss on name recognition alone.

San Diego County Credit Union Poinsettia Bowl
Boise State vs. TCU
Hey with a whopping 14 syllables we have a new leader in the clubhouse for longest bowl name. I don't know if this length can be topped. It's like DiMaggio's hit streak or Wilt's 100 points, the bar is just set too high. The crazy thing is, this is actually a very good game. Or at least it should be. The strength of the C-USA and the WAC will be revealed as these two battle for the right to have their conference be considered the 8th best conference in college football. I love Boise State, but I think TCU is a better football team and a bad matchup for the Smurf Turfers.

Sheraton Hawaii Bowl
Hawaii vs. Notre Dame
Charlie Weis gets a chance to at least sorta salvage a disastrous season for the Irish as he tries to get to 7-6. If the Irish drop this one, and there is a strong possibility of just, this will be a truly humiliating year for the Golden Domers at 6-7 and losing to Hawaii in a bowl. The pick here is that the Irish continue to choke in bowl games, losing an incredible 10th in a row to Hawaii at the Rainbows (I refuse to call them the Warriors) home turf.

Motor City Bowl
Florida Atlantic vs. Central Michigan
As if the poor people of Detroit haven't seen enough lousy football this season, they get to watch a bunch of guys who couldn't even make the Lions' roster play in a bowl. This is the worst bowl game I have come across yet. At least it's a Michigan team, though. So for that reason, I'll take Central Michigan.

Meineke Car Care Bowl
West Virginia vs. North Carolina
Another pretty darn good bowl game. Pat White's brilliant college career comes to a close against Butch Davis' rejuvenated UNC squad. White has always been a monster in bowl games, and I'd be shocked if West Virginia didn't go out on top in his final game.

Champs Sports Bowl
Wisconsin vs. Florida State
The Noles looked posed for a shot at the ACC championship game and at worst figured to get a spot in the Gator Bowl just a month ago, but they fell a long way. It was a disappointing finish for both teams, and I doubt either one is too excited for this game. Still, it's right down the road from Tallahassee, so give me Florida State.

Emerald Bowl
Miami vs. Cal
The 'Canes look like they may be on the way back up, as they had an encouraging season under Randy Shannon, but they still aren't The U of old. Playing in California against a very good Cal team won't help them much, either, as California prevails, gouging a pretty bad Hurricanes run defense with stud Jahvid Best.

Independence Bowl
Northern Illinois vs. Louisiana Tech
How bummed must the organizers of this baby be? Normally, they get an SEC/ Big 12 matchup, although its typically two mediocre teams from those two conferences. The last few years they've had Alabama/ Colorado, Oklahoma State/ Alabama and South Carolina/ Missouri. And this year... neither conference could fill their spot, and I think this one surpasses the Motor City Bowl as the worst bowl game of the season. Anyway, give me Louisiana Tech though I have exactly 0% confidence in this.

Papajohns.com Bowl
NC State vs. Rutgers
These two squads are both red-hot coming into this game, and yet... pretty much no one is gonna care. I saw the full force of that Rutgers squad though, and they looked damned good. So give me Rutgers.

Valero Alamo Bowl
Missouri vs. Northwestern
Remember how excited everyone was for Mizzou earlier this season? Remember how close they came to playing for the Ship last season? So much for all of that Mizzou hype, and if this kind of thing continues happening, that's how good coaches like Gary Pinkel get their walking papers. Still, Missouri is way too good to lose to a lower tier Big Eleven squad.

Roady's Humanitarian Bowl
Maryland vs. Nevada
Maryland looked like a decent bet to make the ACC Championship game just a few weeks ago in that parity-riddled conference, but they collapsed on themselves and now instead of living it up on South Beach they are zipping up the parkas as they walk around Boise. Talk about depressing. And now they get to take on a very underrated Nevada squad led by Colin Kaepernick. I'll take Nevada to knock of the Terps.

Texas Bowl
Western Michigan vs. Rice
Yet another game that you really can't even get a little bit excited about. Rice will be playing in their backyard, so the Owls have a serious advantage. Chase Clement leads the high octane Rice offense to victory.

Pacific Life Holiday Bowl
Oklahoma State vs. Oregon
This should be a pretty entertaining game. The Ducks represent the Pac-10 pretty much perfectly, as they are as underrated a squad as you'll find anywhere. The Ducks struggle to move the ball in the air, but are one of the most dominant rushing teams in the country. And Okie State is apparently the one Big 12 squad that doesn't throw it a million times a game, so we can expect a heavy dose of the ground game for both sides. Give me Oklahoma State because of the experience they have playing some of the best teams in the country.

Bell Helicopter Armed Forces Bowl
Houston vs. Air Force
The Air Force squad somehow throws for less than 100 yards a game while Houston goes for over 400 a game in the passing game, second only to that zany Mike Leach and his Red Raiders. Even if this isn't a clash of traditional powers, its still going to be interesting to see the contrasting styles. The high-powered Houston squad is a little too good for Air Force I think, though.

Brut Sun Bowl
Oregon State vs. Pitt
I'm all sorts of fired up for this New Year's Eve Day bash, and let's hope it wraps up the New Year the right way for us Panther fans. Give me Pitt.

Gaylord Hotels Music City Bowl
Boston College vs. Vanderbilt
There were certainly be some sentimentality on the behalf of the 'Dores, playing in their home state in their first bowl game in ages. Despite these factors, I think Boston College is just too good for Vandy to handle.

Insight Bowl
Kansas vs. Minnesota
A year after a breakthrough year for Jayhawks, they fell back to earth this season in the top heavy Big 12. That alone gives me faith in Kansas to to top a similary middle of the pack squad from the much weaker Big 11.

Chick-Fil-A Bowl- aka the Peach Bowl
LSU vs. Georgia Tech
I still think this thing should retain the Peach Bowl moniker, just like the Capital One Bowl should still have the Citrus Bowl moniker. Georgia Tech's triple option offense surprisingly blossomed under Paul Johnson, and with a struggling LSU defense, I'm going to call for the upset as Georgia Tech takes down an overrated Tigers squad.

Outback Bowl
Iowa vs. South Carolina
Shonn Greene was a force of nature this season for the Hawkeyes, and is practically unstoppable for any college D around. That means SC is going to have to score to stay in this one, and with a pretty anemic offense, I just don't see that happening, as Iowa prevails.

Capital One Bowl aka Citrus Bowl
Michigan State vs. Georgia
Javon Ringer turned into one of the biggest workhorse backs in recent college history. Then again, Knowshon Moreno was no slouch himself. Combine Moreno with Matt Stafford, and I just don't see Sparty being able to keep up with Georgia by plunging Ringer for 3 yards and a cloud of dust.

Konica Minolta Gator Bowl
Nebraska vs. Clemson
Who are these Huskers? After years of setting the trend in the Big 12 with their rushing attack, the Big Orange are finally catching up with their conference rivals in the passing department after a 3300 yard season from Joe Ganz. Clemson played better after Tommy Bowden was dumped, but they still have a pretty unproductive offense, much like most of their ACC brethren. For this reason, I'll take Nebraska.

Rose Bowl Game Presented by AT&T
Penn State vs. Southern Cal
Even with all those syllables for the stodgy Grand daddy, the San Diego County Credit Union Poinsettia Bowl is still our winner for most syllables with that 14 number. Anyway, this is a great game coming up, as the wildly talented and explosive Southern Cal team takes on Penn State in its rejuvenated state. I don't think the Nitts have enough to stay on the field though, so give me USC.

FedEx Orange Bowl
Cincinnati vs. Virginia Tech
Cincy may not be much of a traditional football power, but that is a good club. VT meanwhile will do its typical Beamer Ball antics to keep any game close, no matter who they are playing. As much as I'd like to see the Big East take another W in a BCS game, I think Virginia Tech just has too many factors going its direction in this one.

AT&T Cotton Bowl
Ole Miss vs. Texas Tech
For the Red Raiders, this is a letdown. The Cotton Bowl is a terrific bowl game for this school almost any other year, but they had higher hopes this season. And for Ole Miss, this is just about as good as it gets. Still, despite these emotions, I think Texas Tech just has too much talent for the Rebels to contend with. And one more thing, I'm severely irritated by the decision to move yet another game off of New Year's Day, in this case the Cotton Bowl. It's a crying shame. I miss the days of having 3 and 4 bowls on at the same time and 8-9 bowls on during the entire day. We're now all the way down to just 5. If 1 or 2 of these games are blowouts it's going to be a very disappointing recovery day.

Autozone Liberty Bowl
Kentucky vs. East Carolina
ECU was a frisky squad this year, and are playing about as well now as they were a few months back when they were a BCS darling. Kentucky, like so many of their SEC brethren, had one of the least productive offenses in football, and will likely force ECU into a low-scoring brawl of a game. Kentucky basically collapsed at the end of the season, as they were 4-0, 5-2, and 6-3 at different points but finished at 6-6. After UK's struggles, I have little faith in them, so give me East Carolina in this one.

Allstate Sugar
Utah vs. Alabama
Utah will do its best to stand up for mid majors everywhere. Somewhat luckily for them, no one is going to judge Utah on whether they win or lose, but if they can make it a game and keep it close with the former top team in college football. Also luckily for the mid-majors, Bama doesn't figure to blow out any half decent football team, as they are content to play controlling offense and let their D win the game. I think Utah does make a game of it, but Alabama is going to be too much for them in the end.

International Bowl
Buffalo vs. Connecticut
Imagine how disappointed these two schools must have felt when they realized where they were going. Of course for Buffalo they were excited to win the MAC so they were probably okay with it, but seriously if you are in New England and upstate New York and are getting the chance to go somewhere for a Holiday vacation and you then find out its... Toronto. Ouch. Anyway, that season finale for UConn told me all I needed to know about them. Their QB play will never let them beat a good MAC team like Buffalo.

Tostitos Fiest Bowl
Ohio State vs. Texas
These two schools always find a way to play each other don't they? And its always turned out to be a darn good game. OSU has had a nightmarish run in BCS Bowls of late, and their job doesn't get any easier this year, so I'll take Texas and their high-octane offense led by Heisman finalist Colt McCoy.

GMAC Bowl
Ball State vs. Tulsa
These two squads had very disappointing season-end finishes as they both were upset in their conference championship game. They both have excellent passing games, and this should be a match of high powered offenses. Neither one has played much in the way of talented football squads, so its pretty tough to get a good read on them. Still, Ball State had a better regular season, so for whatever reason, I'm leaning that way.

FedEx BCS National Championship Game
Florida vs. Oklahoma
This figures to be one monster of a football game. Both teams have been matched up against the best of their particular styles, with Florida tackling the extremely defensive and tough Alabama, Georgia, and LSU squads and Oklahoma taming the high octane Texas Tech and Missouri teams, losing only to the equally high octane Texas team. This will be the first time they match up against such contrasting styles. Florida does have a pretty sizable amount of offensive firepower even though they play amongst the grunts of the SEC. I think this will be one of the most high-scoring National Title games we've ever seen, and if that happens, Oklahoma has to be the choice given the team's recent offensive explosions.

Monday, December 8, 2008

The College Football Playoff Selection Show

After a few weeks of projections, here it is folks... Three River Sports' 2008 College Football Playoff Selection Show...

In case you missed it, I put together an article a few weeks back that detailed my personal plan for a college football playoff that seemingly every real college fan in existence wants to see. And I am sure this morning that Texas, Alabama, USC, Utah and even (gulp) Penn State fans wouldn't mind seeing this put into effect this year. And so now that the interminable college football regular season has wrapped up, I can make it official: Here are the seeds, matchups, dates and locations for the 2008 TRS College Football Playoff.

Seeds
1 Oklahoma
2 Florida
3 USC
4 Utah
5 Texas
6 Penn State
7 Cincinnati
8 Virginia Tech
9 Alabama
10 Texas Tech
11 Boise State
12 Ohio State

First Round
Texas vs. Ohio State at Tampa Bay December 20 Noon
Penn State vs. Boise State at Houston December 20 6:00
Cincinnati vs. Texas Techat Orlando December 20 3:00
Virginia Tech vs. Alabama at San Diego December 20 9:00

Second Round
Oklahoma vs. Virginia Tech/ Alabama at New Orleans December 27 3:00
Florida vs. Cincinnati/ Texas Tech at Atlanta December 27 Noon
USC vs. Penn State/ Boise State at Dallas December 27 6:00
Utah vs. Texas/ Ohio State at San Francisco December 27 9:00

Semi-Finals
at Pasadena January 3 8:30
at Phoenix January 3 5:00

National Championship
at Miami January 10 8:30

Also in my system, there will still be bowl games for the rest of the teams. I don't have the energy to go doing all that just now, but will try to get the rest of my proposed post-season up sometime in the next few days.

Friday, December 5, 2008

A Bored Post Just to Irritate The State College Fans


Yet again, I find myself bored of studying for finals and writing papers and whatever else. So in toiling around the internet, I thought I would just make light of yet another arrest on a person involved with the Penn State football team. That's right: The Lion.

Now don't anybody get irritated with me for posting a humorous photo about a DUI incident. The combo of a mascot being in legal troubles for the most legally troubled team in sport and my loathing of Penn State was just too great for me to resist something.

In case you were wondering, 46 players (and 1 mascot) have faced 163 (actually 164 now) criminal charges in the last 6 years, a downright appalling number that should get the school in serious hot water if the NCAA weren't a complete and utter joke and if the State College legal code applied to everyone, instead of the current policy of applying to everyone who isn't under the control of Joe "The Crypt Keeper" Paterno.
But seriously, 46 players arrested in 6 years?!? How on earth does that happen. But hey, the Lions are good this season, so who cares right?

I mean I know my neighborhood, South Oakland, isn't exactly the safest place on earth, but down here the only thing that people are really afraid of are the few vagrants who wander around, and if you are dumb enough to live across the Boulevard of the Allies then you have some ghetto folks wandering around too, but the truth is, mostly all of them are harmless and easy to ignore. Certainly they're easier to ignore then 15 freakin' football players storming into your apartment and beating the living hell out of everyone inside. Seriously, forget Adam Sandler, they should have just hired this entire football team to star in the remake of The Longest Yard if they wanted it to be a real-life documentary about a football team full of criminals.

Wednesday, November 26, 2008

Updated Version of My College Football Playoff

It's been two weeks since I first made my college football playoff proposal in this space and gave the rundown of how it would look as of that point. Anyway I was thinking about that today and decided to update how that playoff system would look if the playoffs started right now, even though there are still two weeks to go in the season. If you need a refresher of the rules, or didn't catch it the first time around, click the above link for the details. So here are my 12 seeds, the matchups that would be produced, and how I think it would shake out.

1- Alabama
2- Texas
3- USC
4- Utah
5- Oklahoma
6- Penn State
7- Cincinnati
8- Florida State
9- Florida
10- Texas Tech
11- Boise State
12- Ohio State

So that would give us the following matchups:
First Round
Byes:Alabama, Texas, USC, Utah
Oklahoma vs. Ohio State at San Diego
Penn State vs. Boise State at Atlanta
Cincinnati vs. Texas Tech at Tampa Bay
Florida State vs. Florida at Houston

Second Round
Oklahoma/Ohio State vs. Alabama at New Orleans
Penn State/Boise State vs. Texas at San Francisco
Cincinnati/Texas Tech vs. USC at Orlando
Florida State/Florida vs. Utah at Dallas

Now try and tell me with a straight face that this tournament wouldn't make a ton of money and get a boatload of national attention. So, here's how I see this all shaking out:
First Round
Oklahoma 41 Ohio State 14- The Sooners roll over an inexperienced Buckeye team that is on it way to greatness, but isn't ready yet. Sam Bradford's potential Heisman campaign continues to gain steam.

Penn State 24 Boise State 10- I love Boise State and certainly have no affection for the Nittany Lions, but this is a case of the little guys not ready to play with the Big Boys. PSU isn't likely to put up any big numbers, but they throw talent at Boise State that the Broncos haven't seen before.

Texas Tech 42 Cincinnati 28- Hey look! It's two teams that got obliterated by Oklahoma. As much as I would love to say that the Big East could pull an upset, this isn't a good match-up for the Bearcats, as the Red Raiders have faced much better spread teams all year in the Big 12 and can easily keep Cincy's O in check while their own O goes to work.

Florida 41 Florida State 21- I must admit, I thought about changing the seeds around because these two teams will meet shortly in the regular season, but for now, the seeds stand, which is horrific news for the Seminoles who can't play with Tebow and company.

Second Round
Alabama 27 Oklahoma 21- The ultimate immovable object vs. unstoppable force game as the Tide's vaunted D takes on the Sooners potent O. The Tide are on too much of a roll, though, Roll Tide Roll.

Texas 31 Penn State 14- Another intriguing game, but the Nittany Lions can't hang with the Longhorns, as Colt McCoy and company coast on through to the semis.

USC 38 Texas Tech 24- USC cements itself as the trendy dark horse type pick with this solid W over the Red Raiders, as the Trojans demonstrate their talent once and for all.

Florida 45 Utah 24- The Utes are playing for the pride of the little guys, but Florida is not the team they wanted to get paired against. The Utes have been excellent this season, but the Gators are sniffing another title, and blow away the slower Mountain West champ.

Semifinals
Alabama 28 Florida 20- The soon-to-be SEC Championship game is played a second time, and the Tide prove victorious in a close one.

USC 41 Texas 31- USC pulls something of an upset as Mark Sanchez continues his excellent play and the Trojans, long considered the most talented team in the country, are clicking on all cylinders.

National Championship
USC 24 Alabama 10- The Tide just don't have enough offensive firepower for this one, as USC's lighting quick D is too much for Bama's offense, and the Trojans are able to muster up enough points to give Pete Carroll that elusive third National Championship.

So there you have it, at least in my mind. Please keep in mind that these projected seeds are based on where we are now, not where I think we will be in two weeks. That would be a whole different look.

So, if you agree, disagree, or just want to let me know how you think it would play out, drop me a line.

Thursday, November 13, 2008

Random Notes from around the Three Rivers

I racked my brain for a good portion of the day and truth be told, I just could not really come up with a truly good idea for a column, so I decided instead I would bounce around the Pittsburgh sports scene and give some commentary on what's going on in our slice of heaven.

-As I am typing this, the Pens are in the midst of a monster collapse against the hated Philadelphia Flyers. Such a huge collapse, in fact, that they pulled Marc-Andre Fleury prior to the third period because he blew a 3-0 lead and it has morphed into a 4-3 tilt in favor of the Fly Guys. It remains to be seen how this one turns out, but I am becoming increasingly concerned with this team's apparent inability to play a complete game. The season is still young and the Pens will undoubtedly have ample time this season to work out some of these kinks, but good teams just don't have these kinds of collapses. When the Pens are on their A game, they can outplay anyone in the league, but these moments just don't come often enough.

-If Big Ben says he is healthy enough to stay on the field, then you know what? I believe him. At no point in his career has Roethlisberger ever shown interest in anything but winning, and I truly don't think personal stats and glory are secondary to this kid, and as much as it may have looked like he was struggling badly in the Indy game (and even he admitted that he was), I am willing to give our Super Bowl winning QB the benefit of the doubt, and let's not forget one thing folks. Despite how well he played in the second half of the Redskins game, there is a reason why Byron Leftwich was run out of Jacksonville and Atlanta and spent several months without so much as a nibble on the free agent market.

-This one goes out to a certain person who is a fan of that largest college in the state. Earlier this year, I heard certain things emanating from State College about a certain math equation that seemed to develop: If Penn State > Oregon State, and Oregon State > Preseason National Championship Favorite Southern Cal, then quite obviously, Penn State > Southern Cal. Now a few months later, I'd like to present the following equation to you crazy Stater fans who pretend not to care about Pitt, but get all riled up about Pitt anyway: Earlier this season, the following equation developed: Pitt > Iowa. Last weekend, Iowa > Penn State.... Would you like for me to finish that equation??? No? Okay. Well I look forward to the comments anyway.

-Speaking of my beloved Panthers, it is going to be unbelievably fascinating to see how the goofy Big East shakes out the rest of the way. I know that there are countless college football fans who look down their nose at the Big East, and for some they probably have the right to do so (looking directly at the Big 12 and SEC), but I really believe it is the most parity-filled league, and I think that's a good thing. While it hurts the league's ability to have a truly elite team, it keeps all the fans interested (except of course for Syracuse, who absolutely owns Louisville for some reason, but would likely struggle against Gateway High School), and it also can lead to possible scenarios like the potential 5 team tie that the Big East could have atop its ranks in a few weeks if things break just right.

-I'll be headed to the Panthers' clash with Fairleigh Dickinson at the Pete tomorrow night and will report some impressions afterward. It should be a laugher, meaning there could be some very intriguing looks at the youngsters.

-It's not the least bit surprising to see the Pirates keeping all quiet on their home front while other teams are a wheelin' and a dealin' following last week's meetings. The Bucs don't actually have a ton of potential trade candidates on the roster. Of course, it's almost considered to be a sure thing that Jumpin' Jack Wilson will be dealt, but I think we will see Neal Huntington stand very pat on that one until he gets a good deal, and no good deals are likely to come through until after the elite free agents are off the market.

-Right as I was having a bit of a brain cramp as far as what to write next.... GOAAAAAAAAAAAAALLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLL for Sid the Kid. He comes in from the right circle and drills one past the keeper from his knee. I mean, I know Sid has gotten off to a bit of a slow start (as slow as one can call it when a player is averaging more than a point per game) but this guy absolutely OWNS the Flyers doesn't he? Ever since Dirty Derian Hatcher cheap shotted him and knocked out a tooth he has been a one-man wrecking crew against the Pens biggest rivals. Very exciting stuff, and let's see if the Pens can get another one on the board here in the waning minutes of the third to cap another exciting comeback.

-I've previously postulated, though I don't think in this forum, that I thought that the Big East could be headed for a split down the line that would cause them to lose some of their catholic schools (specifically St. John's, Seton Hall, Providence and DePaul) because of how difficult it has been for these schools to compete since the expansion. But with the announcement of a Providence man, John Marinatto, to replace Mike Tranghese as commissioner, I am going to shelve that prediction. I do think that this could lead to something (I have no idea what) being done to give the Catholic schools a leg up against their much larger competition. I also think that this means this will essentially be a continuation of the Mike Tranghese era, and while that isn't necessarily a bad thing, I think the Big East could have used some new thoughts regarding their incredible uniqueness, and this likely means regurgitated thoughts.

-Remember a year ago when the Pirates were rumored to be getting Kelly Shoppach and Cliff Lee for Jason Bay and it was shot down by the Pirates because it was viewed as not being enough? Well, a year later, after getting some serious question marks in exchange for J-Bay and watching Cliff Lee take home the Cy Young earlier today, I'd say they made the wrong call there. To be fair, most thought it wasn't enough for Bay and hindsight is always 20-20, and yours truly certainly was opposed to it, it probably isn't a great sign when you can say that your GM turned down a deal that would have allowed him to acquire the Cy Young winner at his lowest value of his entire career. Still though, I'm not actually upset with NH, just wanted to bring it up in case anyone forgot.

-Here we go with a SHOOTOUT!!!!!! Petr Sykora shoots first for the Penguinos, and... he shoots it directly into the goalie's pads. Here comes Simon Gagne against Sabourin... and he makes a brilliant poke check! 0-0 after the first round! Next for the Pens is Kris Letang, a shockingly good shoot out man. Here he comes... DENIED by Biron on the forehand, and he even tried to put it in a second time and was denied twice, luckily it only counts once. Next is the dreaded Mike Richards... and Sabourin makes a spectacular save after getting deked out like crazy. Here comes our star Sid the kid.... and he MISSES the net! Damn! That was a poor move by 8-7. Jeff Carter is last... you can feel the tension... SABO MAKES THE SAVE!!! We're going to extra shots. GENO! GENO! GENO! Here comes Malkin...He makes a sick move but can't finish with what Paul Alexander calls the old Peter Forsberg move. Poke check by Biron stops him. Kimmo Timonen skates up... He had Sabo beat but HE HITS THE POST! Next up, sell your soul because here comes Satan!!! Miro is poke checked away by Biron and we are still scoreless after 4 1/2 rounds. Oh man this is nerve wracking. Joffrey Lupul coming in... and SABO makes another one! WOW this is unreal. Here comes the rook, Alex Goligoski...What a MOVE!!!!! HE SCORES!!! Back and forth he snaked and he knocked it around Biron. Here comes the hated thug Scotty Hartnell... I hope he breaks his neck... and Sabourin poke checks it out!!!!! PENS WIN! PENS WIN! PENS WIN! What a performance by Dany Sabourin in relief, and that jerk Hartnell, after getting stopped, bowls over Sabourin in a typically ridiculously dirty play and talks trash on him. Ooohh Man do I hate that guy. It doesn't matter though because that loser choked!!!!!! Pens with their second monster comeback in a row! On that note, I think I will call it a column here with this little strem of consciousness-y account of the Pens shootout. Good Fight, Good Night!

Wednesday, November 12, 2008

PLAYOFFS?!?

That's right folks, every respected college football writer has pumped out a version of their own playoffs, so sit back and enjoy while a complete amateur (myself) pumps out his own version of a college football playoff system, and then follows up with it in a few weeks with my own selection show (a real treat that I am already mapping out). Let me add this one caveat: While of course I don't know any actual insider tips and haven't talked to any influential minds, I honestly believe that I've watched more college football then many writers this season, and I know I've probably read more about college football than just about anyone, as the sport fascinates me for some reason and I read every single article that I can find.

So without further ado, here is my college football playoff system, to be put into affect immediately:

I understand that many of the most powerful people in the sport want to preserve the importance of the college football regular season, so with that in mind, I have designed a 12 team playoff system, which I feel actually gives more credibility to the regular season than an 8 team playoff, as the teams with the teams that are judged to be the best 4 would get a serious advantage over the other 8 in the field by having a bye into the quarterfinals.

The BCS system as we know it would actually still play a very important role in my system, as this would be primary tool that the NCAA Playoff committee would use in their seeding process. That's right, I intend to put a committee to work, as the human mind can grasp certain things that a computer can't, and there also really would not be a large amount of areas that they would be able to incorporate human discretion into, but just in case, they will be there anyway.

Here's how the process would work. In early December, after all teams had finished up their regular season and conference championships, the final BCS Standings would be released, or maybe kept private for the knowledge of the committee only, whichever the NCAA is more comfortable with, and then the Sunday following the end of the regular season the committee would get together and establish the 12 seeds and the matchups with these guidelines to follow that would more or less set the field on their own:

1)The conference champions from the "Big 6" BCS Conferences get automatic bids to the playoff, no matter what their record or their rank in the BCS is. The current structure regarding 5 year evaluation of the performance of the conferences stands as is to ensure that the best 6 conferences really are the ones getting the automatic bids.

2) The highest ranked non-BCS conference champion receives an automatic bid to the playoff.

3) If there is a second non-BCS conference champion ranked in the top 10, they also receive an automatic bid. Any other non-BCS conference champions that make it into the tournament will do so at the discretion of the selection committee, which means they will have to be ranked appropriately by the BCS standings.

4)In any given year, there will be no more than 5 at-large bids available, and there could even be as few as 1 if the non-BCS conferences are unbelievably strong (a near impossibility). The BCS committee must go in order of the top 6 of the BCS rankings in handing out the at-large bids. (i.e. If there were only 3 at-large slots available and the 3-6 seeds were all non-champions, the 3,4, and 5 would receive at large slots and the 6 would be left out in the cold.)

5)After all of the above stipulations are filled, if there are still at-large slots available, the selection committee then fills the remaining slots with teams of their choosing. They can only select teams in the top 12.

6)Lastly, and this rule supersedes any of the rules regarding the at-large bids, no conference can have more than 3 total teams in the playoffs.

So the above guidelines will give us our 12 teams for the playoffs, and let me do a little bit of explaining regarding the above rules before I continue to some rules regarding seeding. First, of course the Big 6 champs will always get their automatic bids, and I am also a big believe in letting at least the best of the rest (meaning the best of the Little 5 conferences) have a shot at the title, and I also know that the strength of these conferences can be pretty cyclical, hence why I included the provision for a second team being in the top 16. The reason I picked 16 when there are 12 teams is because these teams are at a disadvantage to begin with, and especially in the case of the MAC and other of the littlest of the little 5 conferences, a team could potentially go 12-0 and still not make it into the top 12. The top 16 gives them a little more leeway. However, this only goes for a second team in the top 16, as if there are to be 3 or more Little 5 schools, then they all have to be in the top 12, something I doubt we'll ever see, even in this age of parity.

Lastly, there is the issue of giving the committee discretion in choosing some of the last seeds. Those in the top 6 of the BCS naturally deserve their fair shake even if they are not conference champs, but from there, I'm just not entirely comfortable with having straight up numbers decide who makes it, as these are the same numbers that have given us BCS championship games involving teams that didn't even play for their confernece championship, let alone win it. So sorry if I don't want to put my full trust in this system, but I think humans can give us the discretion necessary to make sure the BCS doesn't make any funky decisions.

Finally, the final rule given above, the 3-teams-per-conference rule. I mean, if you can't be considered one of the top 3 teams in your own conference, should you really be allowed to play for the national championship? I say no.

And now, on to our seeding rules:
1) The four teams that receive byes must all be conference champions. They can be a conference champion from any conference, so long as they have won their conference championship, they can get a bye.

2) The 6 BCS conference champions are guaranteed spots in the top 8, meaning no BCS conference champ can play another in the first round. If, by some minor miracle, there are more than 2 non-BCS championship schools in the top 4, as many BCS champions as possible are put into the top 8.

3) No teams from the same conference can play each other in the first round. This is where the discretion of the selection committee comes in to play.

4) Any remaining seeding decisions lie in the hands of the committee, but they are urged to use the BCS Standings as a guide, though again, they have discretion.

And now for the sites:
-The National Championship (at it is henceforth known) will be rotated among the current 4 sites: Pasadena, Phoenix, Miami, and New Orleans. These four go in a rotation for one quarterfinal, two semifinals, and of course, the final.

-This leaves us with 7 sites remaining. Here are my picks for the best sites: Tampa Bay, Atlanta, Dallas, San Diego, Houston, Orlando, and San Francisco. The committee is to do its best to avoid placing teams in sites that give them a home field advantage. Again, the committee is given discretion here.

Just to give you an idea of what this system would do right now, here's what this field would likely look like right now.

Seeds:
1- Alabama
2- Texas Tech
3- USC
4- Utah
5- Texas
6- Penn State
7- Florida State
8- Pitt
9- Florida
10- Oklahoma
11- Boise State
12- Georgia

That would give us matchups that look like this:
5) Texas vs. 12) Georgia at San Diego
6) Penn State vs. 11) Boise State at Orlando
7) Florida State vs. 10) Oklahoma at Atlanta
8) Pitt vs. 9) Florida at San Francisco

The second round: Atlanta, Dallas
1) Alabama vs. Pitt/ Florida at Atlanta
2) Texas Tech vs. Florida State/ Oklahoma State at New Orleans
3) USC vs. Penn State/ Boise State at Houston
4) Utah vs. Texas/ Georgia at Tampa Bay

Now tell me those games wouldn't generate an absolute TON of money for college football.

Of course, this is just the beginning of my recommendations for revamping college football, but I am going to leave it at this for now, as I think this column is long enough already.

Sunday, November 9, 2008

The Weekend Review

For those of you who are legit Pittsburgh sports fans, the first 98% or so of the weekend went very, very well. The final 2% though was quite crushing.
Consider, these highlights, in chronological order:
-The Penguins started the weekend off a bit early by holding on for dear life with a 5-4 win over the Oilers where they jumped out in front 5 zip, then proceeded to soil themselves for the final 25 minutes of the game.
-The high school football playoffs for the WPIAL went into full swing Friday night with the quarterfinals, always an exciting team, regardless of what team you pull for.
-The Pitt Panthers got Saturday started off the right way, with a 41-7 drubbing of Louisville, cementing themselves as a serious contender for the Big East crown with just three games to go in the season. They also pretty much clinched their first bowl game in since 2004.
-The Penn State Nittany Lions dropped a heartbreaker to Iowa Saturday evening 24-23 on a last second field goal that warmed any Pitt fan's heart. (Sorry Nitter fans, if you are looking for a Pittsburgh site that also supports your squad, this sure as hell ain't it.)
-The West Virginia Mountaineers lost to Cincinnati in OT, continuing a season long underachieving run for the back woods bunch.
-The Pitt basketball team looked crisp in an exhibition win over LaRoche.
-The Steelers took a very tough loss just moments ago to the Colts, 24-20. I can't rationally discuss this one right now, so here's the rest of the highlights, with one mini-rant about the Steelers.

So, all in all, it was a simply spectacular weekend for yours truly, as my rivals lost, and my faves won. Just good times all around. Here are some assorted thoughts from the weekend:
-Pitt football heads into one of the most critical stretches its football program has seen in years, maybe even decades. Running the table would put them in the BCS, and while they did achieve that feat 4 years ago, it was in a very watered Big East, whereas the league nowadays is a very underrated and chippy conference.

-Jonathan Baldwin is an absolute beast and if Bill Stull knew how to throw a deep ball, this kid would be a Freshman All-American. He is going to be a legit special player when he becomes the focal point of the offense when Shady McCoy leaves after this season.

-Speaking of McCoy, he had a rough go of it against the Cardinals, as his numbers looked dreadful, but he still came through with two big runs (a touchdown run and a run to inside the 5 on another drive) and I think he'll rebound in a big way against Cincinnati.

-The Pens certainly like to keep their games interested don't they? Right now they look like they lack that killer instinct, and they certainly aren't putting teams away when they have the chance. I think this develops over time once they develop some better chemistry with their lines.

-I think one thing hardly anyone is mentioning is that this team really, really misses Sergei Gonchar, and doesn't miss Ryan Whitney at all. Gonch was a legit Norris candidate last season, and while he is best known for his offensive play from the point, he was a steadying force on defense, and put up the best blue line play I have ever seen out of a Penguin in my 15 or so years of watching this team. Whitney, on the other hand, looks more and more like a trade candidate when he comes back every day. Kris Letang and Alex Goligoski have stepped up and filled his role as offensive defensemen very well, and honestly I think Letang is already a better player then Whitney, at least the Whitney we saw at the end of last season. A year ago I thought the Whitney contract was a little on the large side, but worth it to lock up a future All-Star defender. Now, I think it's the one true mistake that Ray Shero has made in his tenure as General Manager.

-I can already sense the "Sidney Crosby is slumping" and "Is Malkin the real star of the Penguins?" articles that we know are coming if Sid continues to struggle to put points (especially goals) on the stat sheet. Look., folks, Sid started off a little on the slow side a year ago and still put up very good numbers before his injury, and I don't really know that he will be a 40 goal scorer type for a few more seasons, when he begins hitting his phyical peak. Still, he's scoring at a rate higher than most, and he scares the daylights out of opposing coaches. Sid will be fine, and will be a lot finer if Ray Shero can conjure a winger up for him at some point this season.

-I don't spend much time on Penn State and/or WVU on this site, as I loathe both schools quite a bit, but that was one real tough loss yesterday for the State Penn fans. Of course, in case you didn't know PSUers, the old P-I-T-T knocked off Iowa earlier this season. By a point. The same amount that Iowa beat you by. Care for a little lesson in comparison logic?

-The Steelers, prior to this week, have been ranked 3rd in virtually all 3.4 million power polls done worldwide, but frankly if that's true, then this is a really weak NFL season. This Steeler team would have been slaughtered by numerous past Steeler squads, and in the top heavy AFC of a few seasons ago, would have been hard pressed to make it to the post-season. I'll give the defense a ton of credit for being incredibly stifling and the absolute driving force. But the offense makes me a little bit queasy. Large Benjamin has been way too careless with the ball all season long. That offensive line is a disaster mixed with a catastrophe. The injury bug has hit them unbelievably hard considering its only mid season. They have had too many thin drafts the past few years and it is catching up to them on the depth chart. Hines Ward is firmly on the downhill slope of his career but is still our main weapon. Santonio Holmes continues to be unable to develop into the superstar receiver his talent would suggest he can be. Mewelde Moore is the only thing resembling an NFL running back on the healthy roster right now. This is really just a sampling of their problems, but they are the real reasons why, unless this team really develops over the next few weeks, I just can't pick them to be a Super Bowl contender right now. Of course, I would have said the same thing back in the 05/06 season as late as 12 games into it, and that season turned out pretty darn well, so you never know...

-I am all kinds of fired up for Pitt basketball this season. Our freshman look like they should all be more than ready to contribute this season, but having the veteran core should enable our brilliant coach Jamie Dixon to avoid having too heap too much pressure on them. I do think that one of the four freshman takes a redshirt, though, as I can't figure out how there will be enough minutes to go around for all of them otherwise, but we will see.