Showing posts with label West Virginia. Show all posts
Showing posts with label West Virginia. Show all posts

Saturday, March 14, 2009

Truly Bizarre Games Probably Lock Up A 1 Seed For Pitt

After Pitt's humbling loss to WVU, I postulated that there was a definite chance that the Panthers' previously "locked up" number 1 seed might not be so locked up after all if certain events were to transpire.

So much for that.

Basically every other contender for a 1 seed besides Louisville and Memphis (who doesn't count because they play their games against Little Sisters of the Poor) has been upset in the past few days, to the point that things have essentially been reset to where they were at the beginning of the week. And that of course means that the Panthers are just about locked in a top seed.

It may not be exactly how I imagined this week going, and certainly there are still kinks to be a bit worried about as the Panthers approach the Big Dance, but after watching the quintet of Kansas, Oklahoma, North Carolina, Connecticut and Michigan State all match Pitt's losing effort, we figure to be celebrating the first number 1 seed in school history tomorrow night.

Of course, after a few moments of talking about it being cool to be a 1 seed, it is right back to work and back to focusing on the task at hand, which of course is making a legit run at the national championship and breaking through the Sweet 16 barrier that has toyed with our emotions the past several seasons.

On an semi-related note: It would be kinda cool to see Duquesne win tonight, right? Personally I have absolutely nothing against the Dukes and have a number of friends that go there and who weren't even aware Duquesne still had a basketball program until the past couple days. In all seriousness, though, it would be especially cool because a win would mean that (potentially) all the main local teams would be dancing this year. Our Panthers are obviously in, probably as a 1 seed. Bobby Mo wrapped up the NEC title a few days ago and are being projected around a 14 or so. The Dukes, if they win, would probably fall around a 12 or 13. West Virginia is a lock for an at-large and I'd venture a guess that they'll be around a 6 seed or so. And Penn State currently resides on the bubble of the at-large teams, but they have at least a decent chance to get in and would likely get either an 11 or 12 seed.

It'd be cool to see which ones of the local squads enjoy the most success. I personally am hoping that it happens.

Thursday, March 12, 2009

Terrible Night

Wow, talk about a letdown of an evening in the Pittsburgh sports scene.

If you read this blog much, you know my ultimate sports passion is with the Pitt Panthers, and specifically with their basketball squad. So needless to say, that alone made this was a pretty atrocious evening for me.

And then that gets topped off with a Pens game that got my hopes up thanks to a superb comeback, and yet the Pens came up short in a dramatic shootout. Few things sting more than a close shootout loss, and this was especially true tonight.

I don't think I have the energy or the masochistic mentality for a big-time recap of either, so here are some random thoughts while I try to figure out what the hell I'm going to do for the next two nights in semi-abandoned Oakland now that the Panthers aren't going to be playing.

-I'm refusing to get too worked up over this loss, as there is a much larger goal in mind here than the Big East Championship. (By the way, what's with the decision to call the Big East Tournament the Big East Championship this season? I haven't the BET moniker even once. Weird.) If you play a solid team like WVU three times in a season, there is a very,very, very, very good chance that you lose once. They are too good of a team and have too many frisky players like Ruoff and Butler to expect to beat them three teams in a season. So don't go tip-toeing out onto the ledge for this one Pitt fans.

-All that said, I hate losing to the damn Hoopies.

-Is anyone else a bit unconvinced by the claims by several analysts that Pitt has a number 1 seed locked up despite this loss? I'm not sure I buy that it's locked up. Think about this hypothetical. UConn and Louisville both make it to the Big East Championship Game (note I am writing this before the UConn game has ended, so if they end up losing to the Cuse don't blame me for this being a stupid idea). That game ends up being a very close game that the Ville wins. UConn and Louisville both have to have number 1 seeds, right? Right. Then, North Carolina dismantles the ACC predictably and also has to snag a number 1 seed, right? Right. I would agree that Pitt is the odds-on favorite for the 4th 1 seed, but I don't think it's a lock. What if Memphis debacles the rest of the C-USA in their tournament? They'd have to be in the discussion right? Or say if Michigan State steamrolls the Big Eleven in that tournament, then they have to be in the discussion right? Hell, what if Wake pulls a big surprise and upends UNC in the ACC Tournament and wins that? UNC still probably gets a 1 right? Then Wake has to be given a long look for a 1, too. I'm just sayin' folks. It doesn't pay to back into the Big Dance.

-I've said it before, and I have a sinking feeling I'm going to have to say it again: DeJuan Blair really needs to grow the hell up. The T was him trying to get a stupid cheap shot in. That was useless and pointless and moronic. Why take the chance that the refs will call that? His other fouls were all just about as dumb. The attempt at taking a charge almost caused me to throw my HDTV out the window even though I was watching the game with about 7 other people at my apartment. DeJuan, you are a tremendous talent and one of the most superb talents I have ever seen wear the Panther uni, but you are driving me batty with the way you constantly have those brain farts out there on the court. Aaaarrgh...just maddening.

-There wasn't one player who played a good game tonight for Pitt. There. I said it. And that's all the further I'm going to get into criticizing of the players for tonight's game.

-Now I may not want to criticize the players...but be damn sure I am going to throw the refs under the damn bus and then back over them 12 or 13 times. I want to preface this complaint by saying that I don't think good refs (not that they exist in college hoops) would have helped Pitt, as they were flat-out outplayed tonight. Keeping that in mind: Jim Burr is a freaking joke. Seriously. I f-ing hate that guy. He is a waste of human life. He has mental capabilities equal to that of Bilo Sagdiyev. Or, as he's better know, this guy's brother. And in case you aren't aware, Bilo was kept in a cage, was described as having a very small head and 204 teeth, and was taunted sexually by his sister because he couldn't have sex with her until of course he broke out of his cage... and well I've probably gone too far. But to me that sounds like a dead ringer for Burr's personal life. And yet there he is, officiating college basketball games. That's encouraging.

-As for the Pens...I mean I'm just pleased we got a point out of that game. I was flipping to it during commercials, and after seeing the Pens go down 2-0 in the second and 3-0 in the third, I thought we were pretty much dunzo. The Pens showed a lot of heart coming back like they did, and there's no shame in squeezing a point out of a tough road game in which you came out totally flat-footed against a foreign opponent like the BJ's. (Infinitely better name than the Blue Jackets)

-Scoreboard/ Standing watching update:
So really we are about even with the Rangers, who have played 1 less and have 1 less point, and we are definitively ahead of Carolina and Buffalo and slightly ahead of Florida, which has 1 less game played and 2 less points. We now get Ottawa Saturday afternoon, and it will be worth watching how the Pens respond after finally having their win streak run out.

-I don't know where in God's name that burst of energy came from in the third period, but if we could've played like that for even an entire period this would've been going in the W column. Consistency still is an issue for the Pens, and I'm not sure how to figure that out exactly.

-I'm glad we at least managed a power play goal tonight. The power play has been the one lacking thing during the recent hot streak under Bylsma. One goal doesn't exactly do a ton to reassure me, but it is a starting point at least. I will be closely watching that unit in the coming weeks, as re-establishing the PP as a terrifying threat is a necessity to postseason success.

-Lastly, a TRS site update. I'm going to be putting together another NFL Mock Draft, my fourth, and it should be up either tomorrow or Saturday. I'm planning on making it a two-rounder this time, but we'll see what happens.

Sunday, March 8, 2009

TRS All Big East Team

UPDATE: I guess the Big East now just names the top 6 players to the All-league squad. Not sure what changed, as that used to be 11 (it was last season). I don't like the much, much smaller team, and can't figure out how the hell they can claim there are 11 players better than Levance. Maybe they are naming a coaches team or something too. Not sure what's up. If I were to just name 6 to the first team, they'd be: Blair, Young, Thabeet, McNeal, Williams and Harangody. I'd find room for Fields on the second team.

I'm really not sure what day the All Big East squads get announced, but I'd have to assume it is sometime in the next couple days prior to the BET. Unfortunately, I can't trust those coaches to do the right thing, especially when guys like Jerry Wainwright and Fred Hill have the same amount of say as coaching icons like Jim Boeheim and Jim Calhoun and up-and-coming coaching stars like Jamie Dixon and Jay Wright. I'm not even sure Wainwright is familiar with what good basketball looks like. If he is going off his team as a model I think he might vote Gary McGhee as the Player of the Year.

Anyway, because I can't trust these results because of the idiocy of some coaches and the politicking of others, I figured I needed to pump out my own All Big East teams, complete with the same numbers of players as the coaches team will have on the teams (11 on the first and 10 on the second as well as 6 honorable mentions). I'm really not sure what kind of All-Anything basketball team can have 11 players, and can be chosen with no regard to position, but that's how the Big East rolls.

So let's get to it:
First Team
F Sam Young Pitt
F DeJuan Blair Pitt
G Levance Fields Pitt
F Luke Harangody Notre Dame
C Hasheem Thabeet Connecticut
F Terrance Williams Louisville
G Jerel McNeal Marquette
G Jonny Flynn Syracuse
F Earl Clark Louisville
F Dante Cunningham Villanova
G A.J. Price Connecticut

Second Team
F Jeff Adrien Connecticut
G Deonta Vaughn Cincinnati
G Wesley Matthews Marquette
F Lazar Hayward Marquette
G Jeremy Hazell Seton Hall
G Dominique Jones South Florida
G Eric Devendorf Syracuse
F Paul Harris Syracuse
G Scottie Reynolds Villanova
F Da'Sean Butler West Virginia

Honorable Mention
G Weyinmi Efejuku Providence
G Alex Ruoff West Virginia
G Kyle McAlarney Notre Dame
G Dominic James Marquette
C Greg Monroe Georgetown
F Dar Tucker DePaul

Seriously, can you imagine if the Big East went to the traditional 5 or 6 man teams? That'd be insanity. I had a hard enough time paring down the First Team to 11 and the Second Team to 10. It was splitting hairs between Clark, Cunningham, Price, Adrien and Matthews for the first team, and the same thing goes for leaving off Efejuku and Ruoff from the second team and including Butler. I will be very interested to see how this plays out. I also couldn't decide what to do with Dominic James. He would have probably been a borderline first teamer had he stayed healthy, but I'm not sure what will happen now. Honorable mention seemed good enough, but I wouldn't be surprised to see him make his way onto the second team out of respect for what he has done.

Tuesday, February 10, 2009

Panthers Continue Owning the Eers

I could really get used to this. You know, absolutely owning our archrivals in the two major college sports.

The warning signs were all there early in the first half when Panther fans the world over cursed DeJuan Blair's occasional oafishness as he got into foul trouble yet again. When Blair gets in foul trouble against quality squads, too often we've seen the opposing team just start pwning the Panthers. And then Levance Fields racked up his second foul of the first half a bit later and once again we were left cussing at the situation. With both our floor general and our MVP sitting on the bench for a solid portion of the first half, things certainly weren't looking good. Only one man was going to be able to rescue the Panthers:

Sam I Am Young. Of course, while Sam I Am was very good and finally snapped himself out of the slight funk he was, he wasn't alone. Ashton Gibbs continues to develop a hell of a shot, Jermaine Dixon and Tyrell Biggs are the quintessential defensive stoppers/ offensive role players, and Brad Wanamaker and Gil Brown gave solid, steady minutes off the bench.

But the night was Sammy's. Too often he has been overshadowed by the blossoming star of the Grizzly Blair, but that wasn't the case tonight. Even after Blair returned to the lineup in the second half, it wasn't for long and he wasn't effective. After picking up a third foul, this time Blair joined the Pitt fans in their cursing and was promptly T-ed up for his effort. Not good times. Terrifying times, in fact. Blair's immaturity could have easily derailed the Panthers during a big run, but thankfully the leadership of Fieldsy and Sam I Am held the Panthers steady.

This W gives Pitt wins in 5 of their past 6 and 12 of the last 16 hardwood meetings against the Mountaineers. And of course they also have back-to-back W's on the gridiron as well. Not too shabby at all. Few things make me laugh as much as hearing the entire Pitt student section chant "start your tractors" and "We have cable" at the fleeing Mountie fans. Aahhhhh college.

Before I go, one more note: I continue to be vehemently against the Pitt Gold third uniforms. They aren't as bad as the catastrophically terrible all-Gold football uniforms that make the players look like Academy Awards, but these are pretty awful, too. I mean listen, guys, I understand the need to put a 3rd uni out there to boost the olllllllld revenue streams, but you need to do better. Much better. The first and most obvious suggestion is to break out the Script Pitt to everyone's delight. It's not even like you'd have to bring that sucker back frequently, just save it for one football and maybe two b-ball games a year. Wear it for Pitt-WVU b-ball and maybe one other b-ball game against Eastern Southern Missouri Valley Community College or something and then break out the Script for a mid-level football game (like Rutgers or UConn or something) to get the fans fired up.

If you don't want to do this, and I understand if you don't because of the desire to stick with the new design and new colors, at least tone the gold down. I mean our colors aren't gold and white with a hint of blue. But you wouldn't know that from looking at this picture: Emphasize that Blue a lot more in these unis. Try out putting the team name and numers in blue maybe. At the very least put blue side bars on the jersey and extend them on the shorts. For football, maybe instead of head-to-toe gold, keep the jerseys and change the pants to either blue with a gold stripe or white with a blue (or maybe even gold) stripe.

Sunday, February 8, 2009

A Big East Power Poll

As I said yesterday, football is done with actual on-field actions, and I can really only do so many NFL offseason posts in the first week after the Super Bowl, so let's focus on something else. For now, that will be the Pitt Panthers and their top 10 basketball team. It seems like every week a new contender emerges in the bloated Big East and a new underdog pulls a monster upset over a previous favorite. So how do we make sense of it all? By puting together the old Power Poll, of course!

The National Title Contenders
1. Connecticut- The Huskies not only are the Big East's top team, right now they are tops in the nation. This is a very, very good squad that is built very well for a run in March. Jeff Adrien, Jerome Dyson, Hasheem Thabeet, and A.J. Price are all star-caliber players and any one is capable of killing you at any time.
2. Louisville- Coming into the season I was very skeptical of Louisville. I felt that too often in the past they had been overrated because of their head coach. This year, however that is certainly not the case. The three headed monster of Terrance Williams, Samardo Samuels, and Earl Clark make this a dangerous squad. Williams is one of the best all-around players in the country. Their big weakness though is at the point guard where career underachieve Edgar Sosa has continued to disappoint.

3. Pitt- Jamie Dixon is doing it again at Pitt. For the past several seasons the knock on the Pitt program has been that they just can't get past the Sweet 16 in March. With this squad though, the Panthers figure to have their best shot ever at advancing. I mean if you can't do it with a core of Sam Young, DeJuan Blair, and Levance Fields with several very good role players, when can you do it?

The Unknown Entity
4. Marquette- To any Marquette fans out there: I know, I know, you were the last undefeated Big East team and are still in second-place in the Big East. But I mean, c'mon. You guys, for some bizarre reason, haven't played anybody yet and just got drubbed by lowly South Florida. Congrats you beat Georgetown and Notre Dame in the midst of their nuclear meltdowns. The 'Nova win was a very good one, I'll give you that, but we'll talk again after you've gone through the wringer from Feb. 25-March 4 when play UConn, at Louisville, and at Pitt in succession. If you get even 1 win there, you get elevated to National Championship Contender. Deal? Deal.

The Sleeper
5. Villanova- I don't think Nova has the juice to consistently knock around the big talent teams often enough to be considered a Final Four/ National Championship squad, but this is still a very good squad. On any given night they could certainly beat any other team if they play to their abilities, but they also have had trouble finishing as they lost close games to Louisville, Nova, and UConn.

Not Ready For Prime-time Players
6. Cincinnati
7. West Virginia
I gave these squads this name and lumped them together in one paragraph because they remind a lot of one another. Not necessarily in their play on the court, but in the way I feel about them. They are both programs on the rise in the Big East, but yet they definitely aren't yet ready to contend for the conference title and consistently play with the top squads. Still, they beat the teams they are supposed and are definitely capable of pulling an upset or two. Barring a collapse they'll both also be dancing.

Still Have Work To Do8. Syracuse
9. Providence
Given the depth and the hyping of this conference, most would consider it a disappointment if at least 8 squads and maybe even 9 don't make the tourney. Well, right now it looks like the league's best hopes for those bids are Syracuse and Providence. Neither is anywhere near in yet, but they are on the right track and with a few more wins over quality squads they should be on the right track to a dancing.
The Overachievers
10. Seton Hall
11. St. John's
Not a lot was expected of these two squads coming into the season and while certainly neither one is really tearing things up, both are making decent enough progress as they try to build their programs up. Neither is going to go dancing, but both have good shots at an NIT bid, which would at least be a decent start. They can also both play with just about anyone in conference.
The Implosions
12. Georgetown
13. Notre Dame
These two traditional powers in the conference came in with several talented players on their roster and reasonably high expectations. That is especially true for the Irish. Yet after solid starts in the Big East both are in the midst of epic collapses. It figures that ND's collapse will cost Mike Brey his job, and while G-town is disappointing they rae also a very young team.
Bad But Not The Worst
14. South Florida
15. Rutgers
USF came into the Big East for football and geographic purposes and it was to the definite detriment of their b-ball program. However after a few years of cellar dwelling the Bulls appear to at least be making some progress. It will be a long journey, but with three wins the Bulls already have as many wins as they ever have since joining the conference. The Knights meanwhile are a program headed in the opposite direction. They may have 1 win, but they are still a mess of a squad.
The Trainwreck
16. DePaul
The Blue Demons came out firing yesterday against Pitt and gave us a brief scare, but that team is really, really bad. They absolutely fell apart the rest of the game. Losing by 19 to Rutgers is downright embarassing. I honestly don't think the will win a game the rest of the year as their schedule is pretty brutal.

Sunday, January 25, 2009

The Backyard Blowout

What a W by Pitt over their archrivals, the West Virginia Mountaineers. The game was close for a long time, but as the second half progressed, the Panthers just blew the doors off of West Virginia 79-67, who just couldn't hang with Pitt's depth, strength, size, speed, and skill. It got so bad that Tiesi and Frye were playing at the end. Obviously a pretty one-sided finish. I love whooping up on the Hoopies. They have that annoying little brother, inferiority complex going when it comes to Pitt. They relish any chance they can get to rub even minor victories in Pitt's face and any time someone even mentions Pitt to a WV fan they start flipping out and yelling "Eat Shit Pitt" and other nonsense like that, completely unprovoked. It's crazy how desperate they are to appear better than Pitt, even though everyone knows they aren't.

Anywho, some thoughts from the game:

-You could tell this game was in West Virginia. Multiple commercials pertained to back-woodsy things like mining, trees, agriculture, coal power, insurance for laborers (specifically truckers), and in-breeding. And I only made up 1 of those things. There were also countless WVU commercials that looked as though a high school A/V Club had produced them.

-The lighting in that dump they call an arena makes it look like you're watching a game in a high school gym where half the lights are burnt out. Then again, it is West Virginia, I guess I shouldn'tbe surprised.

-WVU student section is seriously weak. I mean, they went with the obvious "Ta-ser" chant at Levance, and I can't blame them for that, but it sounded like about 20 people were chanting it. Really, that's the best you can do against your arch-rival? I didn't hear one "Eat shit Pitt" cheer and way too many "Let's Gooooooooo Mountaineers" chants. Try mixing things up guys, it makes things more exciting. They also had a few basically inaudible cheers mixed in there aimed at DeJuan Blair, but I couldn't quite pick up what they were saying, probably something dumb. What's the point of a cheer if no one can understand what you're saying? They are no Oakland Zoo. Also, when Pitt charged back in the first half to bring the game about even, you could've heard a pin drop in there. Even the announcers were commenting on it it was so bad. And the game was tied! I'm not even going to discuss how silent they were once Pitt pulled away.

-Speaking of their fans, I can't remember the last time I saw a fan get tossed out of a game by the refs, but it definitely happened in this one. The refs tossed some dumb hoopie student out of the section. Just hilarious.

-Very exciting to see the 13-9 Backyard Brawl of 2007 highlights! I think WVU fans the state over just simultaneously threw things at their 8 inch black-and-white antenna TV's. Don't forget Mountaineer fans to make the switch to digital. It's coming soon.

-It's evident how feared Levance Fields is when he's in the game. The WVU defense backed waaay off when he was in the game because they pretty much knew they weren't going to be able to force him into any turnovers. You don't notice until Gibbs or Wanamaker starts running the point and the pressure amps up how big the difference is.

-Pitt was streaky from the foul line. They made their first 6 free throws, 4 of which were from DeJuan, but then went back to typical Pitt shooting for a while before finishing well at 15/20 on the day. Still, its a bit frustrating at times and still very much an achilles heel for this team.

-A mess of a start for Sam Young turned into a great day. He picked up 2 fouls with just less than 7 minutes to go in the first half, and then, 7 seconds into the second half, gets called again for an absolute nonsense foul. Just total garbage call by the refs. Even the announcers based it. Not good. Sam came back in at the 15:54 mark and really didn't alter his play at all, strangely. He was still active on defense and nearly got called for a charge that ended up being a blocking foul. That would have been disastrous had it been called on Sam. The gamble may have paid off for Pitt, as Sam starts filling the basket and the Panthers got up too big on WVU and the Hoopies just couldn't get back in it after Sam started playing at his peak level with a 22 point night.

-Levance Fields is very comfortable shooting from inside the 3 point arc, something that you couldn't have said in years past. He finished with 13 points on the day and made 4 regulation field goals out of 6. I think that is the biggest reason for his increased scoring touch. The team is better if he's passing more than shooting, but when a guy like Sam goes out with foul issues, Levance can more than pick up the slack, and that is huge for this team. He also looks to have ironed out some of the earlier issues he had with free throw shooting.

-Another sloppy first half for Pitt. I don't get why this keeps happening, but the Panthers are definitely a second half team. Maybe it's their depth or their strength or their physicality or something like that, but Pitt is soooooo much better in the second half it's scary. It's gotten to the point that I'm expecting it nowadays. If Pitt's up or close at half time I am feeling pretty good about our chances (the Louisville game aside, of course). WVU looked absolutely exhausted at the end.

-Nas Robinson giving very high quality minutes right now. His athleticism is superb. I think he might be taking some minutes from Biggs, and is definitely the reason that Gary McGhee's playing time has absolutely vanished. Jamie would rather have Nas at the 4 and Biggsy at the 5 and go a little small than play the worthless McGhee. And frankly, I couldn't agree more with this philosophy. If they want to play a speed game, Robinson could be a superb weapon.

-Tyrell Biggs looked badly hurt late in the first half. Appeared to be an ankle thing. He ended up returning but didn't really do a whole lot after that injury. Let's hope he's okay and that this won't turn into a nagging thing.

-Jermaine Dixon was very quiet early, and I briefly fretted that maybe this was going to be a Jermaine Dixon of old performance, but he ended up playing very well in the second half, finishing with 11 points and was an excellent 3/5 from 3-point range, a nice thing to see from him.

-DeJuan Blair staying out of foul trouble was quite pleasant to see. He struggled a bit early with his shot, uncharacteristically missing some buniies, but he rebounded nicely as his physicality overwhelmed the Mountaineers eventually and finished with yet another double-double with a 16 and 11.

-That said, the rest of the team made some silly/ useless fouls. That kind of thing can't continue. Luckily, the Eers spent much of the game doing their best impersonation of Pitt from the foul line as they went just...

All in all, that was a nice win for the Panthers, as they have traditionally struggled mightily in the WVU Crapiseum. The Big Three were critical yet again for the Panthers, as they have been all season, and if these three are clicking on all cylinders, the Panthers will be a very tough team to beat no matter who they are playing.

Tuesday, January 6, 2009

Ranking Dave Wannstedt's Games as a Pitt Coach

1. 12/1/07 at West Virginia W 13-9- Is there any question that this is number one? Of course not. Just a masterful performance in a sign of things to come in 08 by the Wannstache. And don't forget, the Panthers weren't just playing against the Mountaineers, they were playing against all the referees and Mike Tranghese in one of the most crooked and shady games I've ever seen.
2. 11/28/08 vs. West Virginia W 19-15- Beating your rival is never easy, especially when they are at least as talented as you are (I'd argue probably more talented, at least at the skill positions), and it's especially difficult when they are desperate for revenge after the aforementioned 07 monumental upset.
3. 9/20/08 vs. Iowa W 21-20
- This was one of the most underrated and underappreciated games of Wanny's career. It took me most of the season to realize just how good this Iowa team was. While Shonn Greene had a nice day, he was at least somewhat contained, and certainly didn't kill Pitt.
4. 10/2/08 at South Florida W 26-21
- The Bulls were highly rated at the time, but this win gets downgraded because of how badly the Bulls collapsed at the end of the season. Still, it was a hell of a win and got fans legitimately fired up.
5. 10/20/07 vs. Cincinnati W 24-17
- People forget about this game. Cincy came into Pitt as a ranked squad, and after Wanny's career started off about 0-for-10 against ranked teams, the Panthers pulled off a monster win behind terrible quarterback play and just riding Shady until he couldn't do it anymore. This win gave us a preview of how Wanny visualized his program winning games.
6. 11/1/08 at Notre Dame W 36-33
- Few games caused as much celebration, but let's be honest, Notre Dame was a crappy football team this season. Still, without Billy Stull to at least stabilize the offense, this was a surprising win.
7. 9/2/06 vs. Virginia W 38-13- This game gave a lot of us hope at the time. It doesn't matter that a little later on in the season the Panthers absolutely collapsed. A dominating win over an ACC team is a good win.
8. 11/8/08 vs. Louisville W 41-7
- This was one of the most surprising games of the year. Not surprising because Pitt romped over Louisville, but surprising because Pitt romped over Louisville despite Shady being smothered.
9. 10/18/08 at Navy W 42-21
- This wasn't exactly a sexy win, but with every Pitt fan holding their breath after the 07 debacle agains Navy, it was encouraging to see Pitt control the Navy offensive scheme.
10. 9/1/07 vs. Eastern Michigan W 27-3- In Bill Stull's lone start of the 07 season, Pitt dominated Eastern Michigan to get the season off to a great start until...well you know.
11. 12/6/08 at Connecticut W 34-10
- They more than dominated UConn in the second half, but in all honesty, this was a pretty lousy game because of the terrible first half. If UConn didn't trot out a couple of corposes to play quarterback, this might have been a game.
12. 9/8/06 at Cincinnati W 33-15
- With the Panthers looking like they turned a corner, Pitt dominated the Bearcats to keep the River City Trophy or whatever the hell that thing is called. A win over a bowl team was a big one for Pitt, regardless of what bowl they went to.
13. 10/15/05 vs. South Florida W 31-17
- This game was a nice win for Pitt because the type of speed USF always boasts had long been a problem for Pitt teams. It also continued something of a second half comeback for Pitt.
14. 11/16/06 vs. West Virginia L 45-27- The best loss of Wanny's career. It's pretty sad this comes in as high as 14. Sure they lost by 18, but the talent on that field wasn't even comparable. Wanny gets the bonus points for having a halftime lead thanks to the magic of Darrelle Revis. Pitt losing was next to inevitable, but I think this set the tone for Pitt knowing they could hang with WVU in 2007.
15. 11/12/05 vs. Connecticut W 24-0- Granted this was a bad UConn team, but still, a shutout is a shutout is a shutout.
16. 10/22/05 vs. Syracuse W 34-17- This Syracuse team was god awful, but in 05, we'd take a win any way we could get it. Still, it's hard to get too excited over this one.
17. 9/30/06 vs. Toledo W 45-3- A ho-hum, blowout win over a MAC squad. Hard to get too excited.
18. 9/6/08 vs. Buffalo W 27-16
- After the Week 1 debacle against Bowling Green (see below), it was just nice to get any sort of a win. Buffalo turned out to be a half-decent squad, but the problems Pitt had in this game were very concerning.
19. 10/13/06 at UCF W 52-7
- Blowing the doors off of an undermanned UCF squad, even if it is in Orlando, can only get me so excited.
20. 11/22/08 at Cincinnati L 28-21- As frustrating as this game was, Pitt made pretty decent adjustments to Cincy, and Wanny kept the troops focused and they mounted something of a comeback. Not a bad loss considering Cincy's nice season.
21. 12/31/08 Sun Bowl vs. Oregon State L 3-0- Yeah this game furthered my already serious alcoholism problem, but losing by 3 points to Oregon State is no shame. I mean on one hand the D was a work of art out there. Wanny's decision not to overrule Cavanaugh on some of those terrible play calls definitely docks him big time.
22. 10/7/06 vs. Syracuse W 21-11- Another terrible Syracuse team, another game that was closer than it should have been. This seems to be a theme for Wanny against the Orange for some reason.
23. 9/23/06 vs. Citadel W 51-6- As you'll see, romps over lowly I-AA squads don't inspire me too much.
24. 9/24/05 vs. Youngstown State W 41-0- Ditto.
25. 9/8/07 vs. Grambling State W 34-10
- Ditto, except this score was too close for my taste, hence why it goes last. I'm no fan of playing these schools.
26. 11/3/07 vs. Syracuse W 20-17
- Yet another close Cuse game. This Pitt team wasn't very good with Bostick at the helm, but LaRod went off yet again against the Orange.
27. 10/21/06 vs. Rutgers L 20-10
- Hard to fault Wanny too much for this one, as this was a special, team-of-destiny type of Rutgers team. This was the beginning of the end for the 06 Pitt team, as they came in on the cusp of the Top 25, and never recovered from this close loss.
28. 10/8/05 vs. Cincinnati W 38-20- This Bearcat squad was pretty lousy, and Pitt had every reason to beat them. I can't reward Wanny too much for that.
29. 9/15/07 at Michigan State L 17-13
- Not a terrible coaching job because the quarterbacks were unbelievably terrible after the loss of Billy Stull in the EMU game. This will forever go down as the Kevan Smith game.
30. 9/27/08 at Syracuse W 34-24- This talented Pitt team should have blown the doors off of Syracuse, and instead struggled to beat the Orange, needing a 4th quarter comeback to do the job.
31. 11/17/07 at Rutgers L 20-16- Again, with Greg Schiano pulling the strings on a decent, if not spectacular, Rutgers squad against a badly struggling Pitt team, it's hard to be too upset with Wanny.
32. 9/17/05 at Nebraska L 7-6- The game where I became convinced Greg Lee was never going to be an NFL receiver. He caught a pass downfield and was wide open for a score, and all of a sudden started running a 4.9 40-yard dash and was caught from behind before he could score, costing Pitt the game. Not really a huge blemish on Wanny's record, but this was an incredibly frustrating game to watch.
33. 11/24/07 vs. South Florida L 48-37- I was just impressed Pitt put 37 points on the board against the quick USF defense.
34. 11/25/06 vs. Louisville L 48-24
- This was an excellent Louisville squad, so it's hard to fault the coaching, as Bill Cowher couldn't have got the Panthers to a win in this game. However, I remember this game and remember thinking that the Panthers didn't even bother to show up, despite the 24 point output.
35. 9/16/06 vs. Michigan State L 38-23- The Spartans were just too much team for our Panthers in this game. No shame in that, but it was another example of a Panthers squad that had talent but just couldn't really put it together against good squads like MSU.
36. 10/27/07 at Louisville L 24-17- Another frustrating game in a season full of them for the 07 Panthers. With even mediocre QB play, the Panthers take this game.
37. 11/4/06 at South Florida L 22-12- The Panthers were obliterated by the USF D in this game (just 214 yards total). Completely unimaginative playcalling (imagine that) sank the Panthers as they just couldn't match up with the speed the Bulls brought to the table.
38. 9/30/05 at Rutgers L 37-29- A coming-out party for Rutgers. With Pitt's season on life support, the Panthers didn't even bother showing up for the first half, falling behind 27-0 before making a furious, but fruitless comeback. This is something that continues to happen under Wanny even to this day, and is definitely an alarming trend.
39. 9/3/05 vs. Notre Dame L 42-21- Remember all the hype for this ball game? Wanny's first game as coach, College Game Day was in the house, Tyler Palko and the Panthers were coming off a Big East Championship and a Fiesta Bowl bid...and they get just obliterated by Notre Dame. Complete and total buzz kill.
40. 11/3/05 at Louisville L 42-20
- Pitt's defense got debacled in this one, giving up well over 400 yards of total offense in this one. Michael Bush had just 16 carries but went for 115 yards in a game that the Panthers managed to keep it close, trailing just 22-20 at the half, before getting obliterated the rest of the way.
41. 9/22/07 vs. Connecticut L 34-14- Now we're starting to get to the ugly games. This game wasn't nearly as close as the score indicates, an indicator of just how much of a mess the 07 team became immediately after losing Stull.
42. 9/29/07 at Virginia L 44-14- Virginia got up 30-0 on the Panthers in the first half and coasted to an embarassingly easy win over our Panthers. Wanny's crew didn't show up yet again, an alarming trend that sunk the 07 Panthers.
43. 11/24/05 at West Virginia L 45-13
- To not show up at all against your rival is just embarassing and completely inexcusable. Yes, we all knew that WVU was going to win this one 99 times out of 100 given just how toxic the chemistry on this Panthers team was. I think the statisticians from this game are STILL trying to tabulate the rushing yards for Pat White and Steve Slaton.
44. 10/25/08 vs. Rutgers L 54-34
- The 08 Panthers were starting to chug along, things were looking good, we were hoping we could make a run at the Big East, we had a game against a Rutgers team that was falling apart and... BOOM! Mike Teel turns into Peyton Manning and absolutely toasts Aaron Berry and Jovanni Chappel all day long. Just absurd.
45. 8/30/08 vs. Bowling Green L 27-17- There was a fair amount of excitement for the start of the 2008 Pitt season in mid-August. People were fired up for Shady McCoy, fired up to have (we thought) a competent quarterback, and fired up after the 07 Brawl upset. And they lay an egg against a MAC team they should have run circles around. A very disappointing showing for Pitt and for the Wannstache.
46. 10/10/07 vs. Navy L 48-45- We're officially in the dregs now. This game made me want to pull out a rifle and take aim at Paul Rhoads (by the way Iowa State, congrats on your new head coach...no seriously I look forward to Rhoads putting great game plans together for Oklahoma and Texas Tech and keeping things close and then giving up 50 points to Baylor). Anyway, every half decent team eventually slows down the Navy triple option, yet Pitt could just run over. And this is without mentioning that in OT Matt Cavanaugh, with Pitt almost at the goal line, called a Pat Bostick lob into the end zone on fourth and goal when Navy had spent all day running scared from Shady McCoy.
47. 11/11/06 vs. Connecticut L 46-45- Another game that made me want to throw up all over the place. DJ F-Ing Hernandez turned into Tim Tebow in this game. Hernandez threw for 4 touchdowns and ran for 130 of the Huskies 317 rushing yards. You know how many TD's Hernandez would throw for in his career? 6! You know how many rushing yards he has in his career? 306! They turned him into a receiver this season for god's sake! I'm about to black out...(deep breaths)... okay I'm good.
48. 9/9/05 at Ohio L 16-10- The official worst game in the Dave Wannstedt era! This was not a good MAC team, yet they took Pitt to overtime somehow then Tyler Palko, who clearly had wagered heavily on the Bobcats, tossed a lollipop int that was housed for an OU win. And even better, the only TD of the game for Pitt was LaRod's kick return for a TD! I mean how does something like this happen?

Wednesday, December 17, 2008

The Power of the Big East

I'm headed to the Pete tonight to watch our beloved Panthers take on a frisky mid-major in the Siena Saints, a game that, while certainly won't give us much of an indication of Big East play, should at least be something of a challenge for the Panthers, especially early on. I'll report back in tomorrow with my thoughts on the game, and hopefully they are nothing but upbeat and cheery.

On the national college b-ball scene, the red giant known as the Big East continues to make all other conferences look like white dwarves. And yes, that was an astronomy analogy. Deal with it. In the latest Top 25 polls, the Big East has 8 teams in both polls, 6 in the top 15 in the coaches' poll and an astounding 7 in the top 15 in the AP poll. And in all honesty, I think a few others besides those 8 could see time in the Top 25 before the end of the season. West Virginia, as much as I don't like to admit it, is a pretty good team with a fair amount of talent, but that's bound to happen when you have a coach who has consistently run shady programs. Seton Hall, Providence, and St. John's look like they are programs on the rise and have gotten off to strong starts this season and will be teams to reckon with in Big East play, and Cincinnati looks to be headed back up after a few down years. Really, the only teams in the Big East that have struggled thus far are South Florida and DePaul.

I mean that's 12 squads right there that in any other conference would figure to be favorites to earn NCAA bids, yet in the Big East, they will have to fight tooth-and-nail to earn a 7 or 8 seed for most. In my mind, though the Big East deserves double digit bids, they will only get 9, which would be a record. So here's how I break it down on percentage points for the Big East's 16 teams:

UConn 100%
Pitt 100%
Louisville 99%
Notre Dame 98%
Syracuse 95%
Georgetown 85%
Villanova 83%
Marquette 83%
West Virginia 60%
Cincinnati 24%
Seton Hall 23%
Rutgers 20%
Providence 15%
St. John's 12%
DePaul 2%
South Florida 1%

Anyway, all this leads me to my long-standing question: How long can this league really stay intact as is? Though nothing has been public about any trouble in the league, you've really got to wonder how long schools like Seton Hall, DePaul, Providence, and St. John's will really want to stay at the bottom tier of the conference. Big East football will keep bottom-feeding South Florida in-conference for good, but the rest worry me. Especially the three long-time Big Easters there who have exceptional tradition but have watched their success dry up in recent years. I also wonder about Notre Dame, too, even though they have enjoyed success. The latest capsizing football season really makes me wonder if they are edging closer toward coming to their senses and joining the Big Ten for all sports. Of course, there is a slim chance they could just join up with the Big East in football, but that seems unlikely.

I think the appointment of another Providence man as the new Big East commissioner will stave this off temporarily, but it can't be easy for the lesser Catholic schools, who at this point must feel like they are buried alive. I think this peace can only last for so long no matter what, and the bet here is that this Big East, unless we see some parity start to hit the league, is very different 5 years from now. But only time will tell.

Friday, December 12, 2008

The Bowl Poll Picks

It is indeed the most wonderful time of the year! Just to be clear, I'm not talking about Christmas or any other Hallmark-ed up Holiday, I'm talking about the one December holiday season that the card companies haven't picked up on: Bowl Season! Sure, I've made my displeasure with College Football's lack of a playoff system very well known on this site, but it turns out I'm quite good at talking out of both sides of my mouth, because there are few things that put a hop in my step as much as the college football bowl season. And since I am in 2 bowl polls, I figured I would give a rundown of my thought process for each of the 33 completely meaningless games and 1 meaningful game that start next Saturday and finish up Thursday January 8th. Let's get to it...
EagleBank Bowl
Wake Forest vs. Navy
Few things say the start of bowl season liked the historic EagleBank Bowl played in... (Googling "EagleBank Bowl location)...Washington D.C.?!? Really? Who decided it was a good idea to have an outdoor bowl game in December in D.C.? Anyway, this one is Wake Forest vs. Navy. Wake is a sneaky good ACC team, and I watched the Midshipmen get taken apart by my Panthers. The pick here is Wake Forest.

New Mexico Bowl
Colorado State vs. Fresno State
Two squads that were stuck in the middle of the best of the lower conferences doesn't exactly make you want to program the old TiVo does it? I'm leaning toward Colorado State simply because the Mountain West was a better conference than the WAC, and really that's my best reason.

Magicjack St. Petersburg Bowl
South Florida vs. Memphis
I was all fired up this morning when I came across a commercial for Magicjack. I watched the commercial and must say, this is probably the only year that product sponsors a bowl game. Anyway, this game will probably be South Florida heavy even though the Bulls were a god-awful team down the stretch because it's practically played in the Bulls backyard. So with that in mind, I will take the free-falling South Florida squad even though I think they are a mess of a team right now.

Pioneer Las Vegas Bowl
BYU vs. Arizona
This is a pretty good BYU squad that basically runs Las Vegas every December (they've been here 4 years in a row now!) against a mediocre Pac-10 team that is probably just happy to have gotten into a half-decent bowl after a tough finish to the season. I'll take BYU.

R+L Carriers New Orleans Bowl
Southern Miss vs. Troy
10 Syllables is too many for a bowl game to have, although just wait til I get to the next bowl down. Anyway, Southern Miss is a mediocre team in a below-average conference while Troy is the best team in the worst conference. I wonder if that's how this game will be advertised. Probably not. Sun Belt teams are barely Division I-A, so give me Southern Miss on name recognition alone.

San Diego County Credit Union Poinsettia Bowl
Boise State vs. TCU
Hey with a whopping 14 syllables we have a new leader in the clubhouse for longest bowl name. I don't know if this length can be topped. It's like DiMaggio's hit streak or Wilt's 100 points, the bar is just set too high. The crazy thing is, this is actually a very good game. Or at least it should be. The strength of the C-USA and the WAC will be revealed as these two battle for the right to have their conference be considered the 8th best conference in college football. I love Boise State, but I think TCU is a better football team and a bad matchup for the Smurf Turfers.

Sheraton Hawaii Bowl
Hawaii vs. Notre Dame
Charlie Weis gets a chance to at least sorta salvage a disastrous season for the Irish as he tries to get to 7-6. If the Irish drop this one, and there is a strong possibility of just, this will be a truly humiliating year for the Golden Domers at 6-7 and losing to Hawaii in a bowl. The pick here is that the Irish continue to choke in bowl games, losing an incredible 10th in a row to Hawaii at the Rainbows (I refuse to call them the Warriors) home turf.

Motor City Bowl
Florida Atlantic vs. Central Michigan
As if the poor people of Detroit haven't seen enough lousy football this season, they get to watch a bunch of guys who couldn't even make the Lions' roster play in a bowl. This is the worst bowl game I have come across yet. At least it's a Michigan team, though. So for that reason, I'll take Central Michigan.

Meineke Car Care Bowl
West Virginia vs. North Carolina
Another pretty darn good bowl game. Pat White's brilliant college career comes to a close against Butch Davis' rejuvenated UNC squad. White has always been a monster in bowl games, and I'd be shocked if West Virginia didn't go out on top in his final game.

Champs Sports Bowl
Wisconsin vs. Florida State
The Noles looked posed for a shot at the ACC championship game and at worst figured to get a spot in the Gator Bowl just a month ago, but they fell a long way. It was a disappointing finish for both teams, and I doubt either one is too excited for this game. Still, it's right down the road from Tallahassee, so give me Florida State.

Emerald Bowl
Miami vs. Cal
The 'Canes look like they may be on the way back up, as they had an encouraging season under Randy Shannon, but they still aren't The U of old. Playing in California against a very good Cal team won't help them much, either, as California prevails, gouging a pretty bad Hurricanes run defense with stud Jahvid Best.

Independence Bowl
Northern Illinois vs. Louisiana Tech
How bummed must the organizers of this baby be? Normally, they get an SEC/ Big 12 matchup, although its typically two mediocre teams from those two conferences. The last few years they've had Alabama/ Colorado, Oklahoma State/ Alabama and South Carolina/ Missouri. And this year... neither conference could fill their spot, and I think this one surpasses the Motor City Bowl as the worst bowl game of the season. Anyway, give me Louisiana Tech though I have exactly 0% confidence in this.

Papajohns.com Bowl
NC State vs. Rutgers
These two squads are both red-hot coming into this game, and yet... pretty much no one is gonna care. I saw the full force of that Rutgers squad though, and they looked damned good. So give me Rutgers.

Valero Alamo Bowl
Missouri vs. Northwestern
Remember how excited everyone was for Mizzou earlier this season? Remember how close they came to playing for the Ship last season? So much for all of that Mizzou hype, and if this kind of thing continues happening, that's how good coaches like Gary Pinkel get their walking papers. Still, Missouri is way too good to lose to a lower tier Big Eleven squad.

Roady's Humanitarian Bowl
Maryland vs. Nevada
Maryland looked like a decent bet to make the ACC Championship game just a few weeks ago in that parity-riddled conference, but they collapsed on themselves and now instead of living it up on South Beach they are zipping up the parkas as they walk around Boise. Talk about depressing. And now they get to take on a very underrated Nevada squad led by Colin Kaepernick. I'll take Nevada to knock of the Terps.

Texas Bowl
Western Michigan vs. Rice
Yet another game that you really can't even get a little bit excited about. Rice will be playing in their backyard, so the Owls have a serious advantage. Chase Clement leads the high octane Rice offense to victory.

Pacific Life Holiday Bowl
Oklahoma State vs. Oregon
This should be a pretty entertaining game. The Ducks represent the Pac-10 pretty much perfectly, as they are as underrated a squad as you'll find anywhere. The Ducks struggle to move the ball in the air, but are one of the most dominant rushing teams in the country. And Okie State is apparently the one Big 12 squad that doesn't throw it a million times a game, so we can expect a heavy dose of the ground game for both sides. Give me Oklahoma State because of the experience they have playing some of the best teams in the country.

Bell Helicopter Armed Forces Bowl
Houston vs. Air Force
The Air Force squad somehow throws for less than 100 yards a game while Houston goes for over 400 a game in the passing game, second only to that zany Mike Leach and his Red Raiders. Even if this isn't a clash of traditional powers, its still going to be interesting to see the contrasting styles. The high-powered Houston squad is a little too good for Air Force I think, though.

Brut Sun Bowl
Oregon State vs. Pitt
I'm all sorts of fired up for this New Year's Eve Day bash, and let's hope it wraps up the New Year the right way for us Panther fans. Give me Pitt.

Gaylord Hotels Music City Bowl
Boston College vs. Vanderbilt
There were certainly be some sentimentality on the behalf of the 'Dores, playing in their home state in their first bowl game in ages. Despite these factors, I think Boston College is just too good for Vandy to handle.

Insight Bowl
Kansas vs. Minnesota
A year after a breakthrough year for Jayhawks, they fell back to earth this season in the top heavy Big 12. That alone gives me faith in Kansas to to top a similary middle of the pack squad from the much weaker Big 11.

Chick-Fil-A Bowl- aka the Peach Bowl
LSU vs. Georgia Tech
I still think this thing should retain the Peach Bowl moniker, just like the Capital One Bowl should still have the Citrus Bowl moniker. Georgia Tech's triple option offense surprisingly blossomed under Paul Johnson, and with a struggling LSU defense, I'm going to call for the upset as Georgia Tech takes down an overrated Tigers squad.

Outback Bowl
Iowa vs. South Carolina
Shonn Greene was a force of nature this season for the Hawkeyes, and is practically unstoppable for any college D around. That means SC is going to have to score to stay in this one, and with a pretty anemic offense, I just don't see that happening, as Iowa prevails.

Capital One Bowl aka Citrus Bowl
Michigan State vs. Georgia
Javon Ringer turned into one of the biggest workhorse backs in recent college history. Then again, Knowshon Moreno was no slouch himself. Combine Moreno with Matt Stafford, and I just don't see Sparty being able to keep up with Georgia by plunging Ringer for 3 yards and a cloud of dust.

Konica Minolta Gator Bowl
Nebraska vs. Clemson
Who are these Huskers? After years of setting the trend in the Big 12 with their rushing attack, the Big Orange are finally catching up with their conference rivals in the passing department after a 3300 yard season from Joe Ganz. Clemson played better after Tommy Bowden was dumped, but they still have a pretty unproductive offense, much like most of their ACC brethren. For this reason, I'll take Nebraska.

Rose Bowl Game Presented by AT&T
Penn State vs. Southern Cal
Even with all those syllables for the stodgy Grand daddy, the San Diego County Credit Union Poinsettia Bowl is still our winner for most syllables with that 14 number. Anyway, this is a great game coming up, as the wildly talented and explosive Southern Cal team takes on Penn State in its rejuvenated state. I don't think the Nitts have enough to stay on the field though, so give me USC.

FedEx Orange Bowl
Cincinnati vs. Virginia Tech
Cincy may not be much of a traditional football power, but that is a good club. VT meanwhile will do its typical Beamer Ball antics to keep any game close, no matter who they are playing. As much as I'd like to see the Big East take another W in a BCS game, I think Virginia Tech just has too many factors going its direction in this one.

AT&T Cotton Bowl
Ole Miss vs. Texas Tech
For the Red Raiders, this is a letdown. The Cotton Bowl is a terrific bowl game for this school almost any other year, but they had higher hopes this season. And for Ole Miss, this is just about as good as it gets. Still, despite these emotions, I think Texas Tech just has too much talent for the Rebels to contend with. And one more thing, I'm severely irritated by the decision to move yet another game off of New Year's Day, in this case the Cotton Bowl. It's a crying shame. I miss the days of having 3 and 4 bowls on at the same time and 8-9 bowls on during the entire day. We're now all the way down to just 5. If 1 or 2 of these games are blowouts it's going to be a very disappointing recovery day.

Autozone Liberty Bowl
Kentucky vs. East Carolina
ECU was a frisky squad this year, and are playing about as well now as they were a few months back when they were a BCS darling. Kentucky, like so many of their SEC brethren, had one of the least productive offenses in football, and will likely force ECU into a low-scoring brawl of a game. Kentucky basically collapsed at the end of the season, as they were 4-0, 5-2, and 6-3 at different points but finished at 6-6. After UK's struggles, I have little faith in them, so give me East Carolina in this one.

Allstate Sugar
Utah vs. Alabama
Utah will do its best to stand up for mid majors everywhere. Somewhat luckily for them, no one is going to judge Utah on whether they win or lose, but if they can make it a game and keep it close with the former top team in college football. Also luckily for the mid-majors, Bama doesn't figure to blow out any half decent football team, as they are content to play controlling offense and let their D win the game. I think Utah does make a game of it, but Alabama is going to be too much for them in the end.

International Bowl
Buffalo vs. Connecticut
Imagine how disappointed these two schools must have felt when they realized where they were going. Of course for Buffalo they were excited to win the MAC so they were probably okay with it, but seriously if you are in New England and upstate New York and are getting the chance to go somewhere for a Holiday vacation and you then find out its... Toronto. Ouch. Anyway, that season finale for UConn told me all I needed to know about them. Their QB play will never let them beat a good MAC team like Buffalo.

Tostitos Fiest Bowl
Ohio State vs. Texas
These two schools always find a way to play each other don't they? And its always turned out to be a darn good game. OSU has had a nightmarish run in BCS Bowls of late, and their job doesn't get any easier this year, so I'll take Texas and their high-octane offense led by Heisman finalist Colt McCoy.

GMAC Bowl
Ball State vs. Tulsa
These two squads had very disappointing season-end finishes as they both were upset in their conference championship game. They both have excellent passing games, and this should be a match of high powered offenses. Neither one has played much in the way of talented football squads, so its pretty tough to get a good read on them. Still, Ball State had a better regular season, so for whatever reason, I'm leaning that way.

FedEx BCS National Championship Game
Florida vs. Oklahoma
This figures to be one monster of a football game. Both teams have been matched up against the best of their particular styles, with Florida tackling the extremely defensive and tough Alabama, Georgia, and LSU squads and Oklahoma taming the high octane Texas Tech and Missouri teams, losing only to the equally high octane Texas team. This will be the first time they match up against such contrasting styles. Florida does have a pretty sizable amount of offensive firepower even though they play amongst the grunts of the SEC. I think this will be one of the most high-scoring National Title games we've ever seen, and if that happens, Oklahoma has to be the choice given the team's recent offensive explosions.

Saturday, November 29, 2008

How Sweet It Is: Panthers Win the Brawl

I typically reserve my thoughts on specific games that occur over the weekend for my weekly "Weekend Recap" column, but I had to make an exception just this once. I mean come on, it's the Brawl! I just couldn't contain myself until Sunday night/ Monday morning, this is just too special. After watching the Panthers spend the first two years of the Dave Wannstedt era getting run over, around, and through by the Mountaineers, it has been a glorious sight the last two brawls to shut those Hoopies up. And although last season may have been sweet because the Panthers W knocked our rivals out of the National Championship and ended up costing them their coach, thus causing the Mounties more pain than ever before, this win is an even better feeling, at least for me. Last year, after the win, the season was over, and after the celebrating ended, and the fires in Oakland were put out, the Panthers were still 5-7 and staying home for the holidays yet again. This year, though, the Panthers just nabbed their 8th win of the season against the hated Mountaineers, are more than bowl-eligible, will likely slide into the low end of the top 25, and have put themselves in position for a pretty good bowl game if they can win in UConn next weekend. The Dave Wannstedt era, while it is still very much a work-in-progress, has finally delivered some of the fruit that was promised when he arrived on the scene in 2005. There are still times when Wanny and his BFF Matt Cavanaugh will leave Pitt fans scratching their heads with play calls and gameday decisions (like that maddening goal-line opportunity yesterday just before the half), but Wanny has shown he can win, as an 8 win (at least) season is nothing to sneeze at. And, if the Panthers can get another win to give them 9, this would equal the most successful season the Panthers have had in a year since Dan Marino was throwing the ball around back in 1982, as the only other 9 win season since then was Walt Harris' 2002 squad. And to be honest, I'm not sure I can rationally discuss a possible 10-win team yet, so let's not go jinxing it all up just yet.

So without further ado, here are some of my random thoughts from yesterday's game
-Thank the good lord for LeSean McCoy. That man is an absolute beast, and I still find it very difficult to believe he is going to pass up the NFL for another year, but it gets me all kinds of excited nonetheless. If this team didn't have McCoy and had spent the season substituting LaRod Stephens-Howling, Kevin Collier, Shariff Harris, and Chris Burns in for McCoy, this squad would be about 5-6, and hoping to knock off UConn next week to grab a spot in the International Bowl or something like that. And you've got to tip your cap to Wanny for getting McCoy to come here despite all the negative signs around the program at the time. I have no idea how the 'stache does it, but he is one tremendous recruiter.

-Speaking of recruiting, would it kill Wanny to find a better QB? Bill Stull scares the living daylights out of me, and I just really don't see the light at the end of the tunnel. I think he may have even regressed from some of the earlier games this year. I thought he showed some progress in 4 games in a row at midseason against Syracuse, South Florida, Navy, and Rutgers, and was even solid against Louisville after missing the ND game, but was dreadful against Cincinnati and nearly cost them the game yesterday against WVU. I mean at no point was he a guy who you could rely on to win the game for you, and his deep balls have consistently been miserable, but he was at least showing signs of being a good game manager until crapping out the last two weeks.

-My prediction for yesterday's game: Pitt 20 WVU 17. The Final Score: Pitt 19 WVU 15. That's pretty good.

-As I suspected, Phil Bennett clearly studied the game plan that Paul Rhoads put together in last season's Brawl. That Pitt defense, with the exception of that one absurd Pat White run, put the clamps on the vaunted Mountaineer run game, and dared White to beat them with his limp noodle throwing arm. White did an okay job throwing the ball around, and while his receivers had a few key drops that hurt them, White also very predictably made some very bad decisions as well. I also liked Jovani Chappel's quote after the game where he indicated that the Panthers basically knew what the play was going to be on Chappel's pick based simply on how the Mountaineers lined up out of the huddle. Not sure, but that might be an indication you don't have enough passing plays in your playbook.

-Hey, did you know Pitt had a ridiculously talented tight end? Because I sure didn't until I saw Nate Byham have the second best day for any Pitt offensive player yesterday with 4 big catches. So where the heck has this been all season long? I mean, for a struggling QB, isn't a good tight end often times a cure-all and a great security blanket? How has Matt Cavanaugh not called Byham's number more often and more consistently this season for Billy Stull. I mean what's the difference between hitting Byham underneath for 7-8 yards and him getting hit immediately and dropped and Bill Stull tossing one of his 50 bubble screen passes that typically go for about the same, and often don't even do that well.

-Speaking of Matt Cavanaugh, I know we will be coming off (at least) an 8 win season this year, and hopefully more, so there is no chance anyone on the coaching staff is let go, but I still don't think he's a good offensive coordinator. He tries to be too cute and tries to out-think his oppsosition too often. When your team stinks and you don't have enough talent at the skill positions to execute, I completely understand this mentality, as it gives you a way to make up the talent difference, but when you have a future NFL starting running back in your backfield, a deep, if not spectacular, corps of wide recevers, and the aforementioned underrated and underutilized tight end, the cutesy crap isn't necessary. The Byham case I just talked about is one example of this, but situations like the goal-line situation just before halftime yesterday are what really drive me crazy. That drive started with 4:27 to go in the half. The Panthers marched from their own 43 down to the 2 in about 3 minutes. On the drive, either Shady or Stephens-Howling had accounted for all but 4 yards on the drive. Yet, after going to Shady once for a yard on 1st and goal at the 3, Cavanaugh, instead of giving to his goal-line ace McCoy, went for the fade pattern in the end zone, which was promptly intercepted by West Virginia. How is that playing to Pitt's strengths? Is there any way that if you give that ball to McCoy 2 more time he doesn't get in? I mean WVU could have put 22 men on the field and stacked them all in the box, and I still don't think Shady gets denied twice. When you have Eli Manning and Plaxico Burress, or even Rod Rutherford and Larry Fitzgerald for that matter, the fade pattern can work when you are that close, because those receivers know how to play a fade, and those QB's know how to throw one (in Rutherford's case, I think that was the only pass he actually knew how to throw). But when you have a below-average QB with a history of making mistakes and underthrowing throwing to a true freshman wideout who, while wildly talented, is still learning how to play receiver at the college level, a fade pattern into double coverage probably isn't the best option.

-I was wildly impressed with the way Greg Romeus, Jabaal Sheard, Mick Williams, Rashaad Duncan, and the rest of that D-Line played yesterday. Sure Scott McKillop ended up with the big tackle numbers, as he always does, but those D-Linemen were the ones who made the plays. They were smarter than last week against Cincinnati, and instead of going for the big play sack and risking White or Devine breaking free if they got the ball past them, they instead were just as content at getting containment and stopping any chance of screens or outside runs around end. I think all four of these guys have what it takes to play on Sundays some day, and Romeus and Sheard both look like they could be pretty high draft picks if they can keep maturing.

-The Pitt secondary has taken a lot of heat this season, but I think they all did a pretty nice job yesterday, even the much-maligned Aaron Berry and Dom DeCicco. Berry, who has legit NFL talent, still looks like he is relying too much on his natural ability and not enough on smarts and technique, but I think maybe yesterday talent was enough to keep the Mountaineers at least in check. And DeCicco, who had a very nice interception that no really talked about, had probably his best game of the season. Too often he has been caught out of position or has come over to help too late in plays, but I didn't see any of that yesterday, and he also looks like he might finally be using his monstrous size to give him an advantage back there.

-I'll be back tomorrow night with the Weekend Recap, and will probably have a few more things Panthers to add, along with my typical coverage of the Pens, Steelers, Pirates and Pitt Basketball.

Wednesday, November 26, 2008

The Backyard Brawl Preview


It's that time of year again folks... THE BACKYARD BRAWL! Nothing gets the blood pumping for a Pitt fan (and I'm assuming for a WVU fan too) more than talking Pitt/WVU football these days, especially after last season's monumental win for the Panthers that firmly put the Dave Wannstedt Era Panthers on the right path. It also re-ignited a rivalry that, quite frankly, had grown a little stale the previous two seasons as WVU elevated its program to elite national status. This season, the Panthers will head to their first bowl since Walt Harris was whining up and down the sidelines. The Mountaineers, meanwhile, opened the season with sky-high expectations, but their new coach Bill Stewart had some definite growing pains early on in the season. Pat White also had some injury issues that contributed to a wildly disappointing start. Despite a 26-23 loss to Cincinnati three weeks ago, the Mountaineers appear to have righted their ship in time to battle the up-and-coming Panthers. So let's break this puppy down for all to see:

Pitt Offense
It was maddening to watch that Panther offense against Cincinnati. Our beloved blue and gold continued to try to stretch the field with a quarterback who almost never hits on a deep ball, and the offense ignored Shady McCoy for long stretches despite his excellence when he did get the ball. Still, the Panthers saw what Shady did last season against the 'eers and it will be hard even for Matt Cavanaugh to ignore the tape from a year ago and overthink this thing, as he tends to do. It would help the Panthers to have LaRod Stephens-Howling back at full strength after he all but sat out the Cincy game due to injury. Certainly, LaRod is no Shady but he is still an effective offensive weapon to have in the fold. Despite Stull's downfield struggles, Matt Cavanaugh has shown he will continue to try to get the ball to Jonathan Baldwin downfield. If Stull can hit one downfield early on it could make all the difference in the world, and that's what Cavanaugh is going for.

West Virginia Defense
Though their schedule hasn't been the most imposing one around, the Mountaineers Defense has been steady, if unspectacular, when its mattered. They gave up 24 points in their Week 2 upset loss against East Carolina, but even in that game they kept WVU in the game until very late in the third quarter, when the offense's incompetence just cost them too much. In the Cincinnati loss, the Bearcats scored 26 points, a season high against the Mountaineers, but 7 points of that was a kick return for a touchdown, and the Mountie D also forced a safety. This is a team that will keep the score close and relatively low scoring in Friday's game. They did a much better job defending Cincy than our Panthers did, giving up less than 200 yards passing and 100 yards rushing. Stull's tendency to take shots downfield at Cavanaugh's urging could provide an opportunity for West Virginia's defense to create some turnovers. The 'eers have 12 picks on the season, LB Mortty Ivy is the team leader with 3 picks and is very good in coverage, and is a guy the Panthers will have to account for in this game. Sophomore corner Brandon Hogan has come on very strong of late after taking over a starting cornerback spot early in the year.

Pitt Defense
The Panthers had some major issues adjusting to the Bearcats game plan early on, and it was almost embarassing to watch them make career backup Tony Pike look like a future first round pick. Yet the Mounties run a very different scheme than the Bearcats do, and the Panthers have a pretty sound understanding of the WVU offense after watching Pat White run the show for 4 years. Let's hope Phil Bennett has been closely studying the tapes of a year ago when Paul Rhoads, despite all the aggravation of his tenure here, put on an absolute clinic. Scott McKillop was a beast among men in that game last year against WVU, and has similarly been excellent this year, and I would expect similar results Friday. I will be very interested to see what happens with the defensive line this week. We saw Cincinnati execute those sickening screen-type plays several times last week after Pitt's D-Line burst upfield, and it was one of the things that led to the Panthers' demise. WVU has not shown much of a tendency to run those types of plays, but if Romeus, Sheard, Duncan, and Williams are getting past the WVU O-Line early on, I would look for the Mounties to make an effort at incorporating these screens to try to neutralize that disruptive defensive front. And, as always with the Panthers this season, their secondary will leave Panther fans taking a big gasp every time Pat White puts the ball in the air. Thankfully, WVU is one of the most run-happy teams around, and while White and Noel Devine could easily burn the Panthers, I'd rather take my chances with them then a QB who can stretch the field on our porous secondary.

WVU Offense
The Panthers may have an excellent D-Line and a spectacular middle linebacker, but the speed and athleticism of this bunch will be tested, as Noel Devine has emerged as one of the biggest home-run hitters in college football this season. If Devine gets space to move around, the opposition is typically in some deep stuff, so the work of the Panthers depleted outside linebacker corps will be a definite key. However, Devine, while a very dangerous weapon, has also been very inconsistent this season. He has 5 100 yard games, but has also had 3 games where he averaged 3.5 yards per carry or less, with at least 17 carries in each of those 3. As scary as Devine can be though, Pat White is still what makes this offense go. Barring two big games to finish the season (and I am by no means discounting this) White will likely have the lowest rushing total for this season of his brilliant 4 year career, and will almost certainly have the lowest yards-per-carry average as well. The 'eers have developed something of a horizontal, west-coast type passing scheme this season to complement their lethal ground game. Backup running back Jock Sanders has a team-leading 41 catches, a shockingly high number, and Noel Devine is second on the team with 28 grabs of his own. Receiver Alric Arnett and Dorrell Jollah are okay at getting downfield to open up running lanes, but are nowhere near the downfield threats the 'eers have employed in years past like Darius Reynaud and Brandon Myles. All this makes for a strange yet effective offensive scheme where the vast majority of the offense is generated when the end-ball-carrier gets possession at or around the line of scrimmage.

The Bottom Line
The bad blood here should be much worse this year than in the past several years, as the Mounties finally have a reason to respect our Panthers, and they know just how much Pitt cost them a year ago. The Panthers' hopes lie with Shady McCoy, and if he can get some things going early on, it will make all the difference in the world for Pitt. The WVU defense is stingy, though, and I'd be a little surprised to see any patented Shady long TD runs, but all we need is him to run like the guy who won that WVU game last season. The Mountaineers will need Pat White to have another monster game, and any Panther fan who tells you he's not absolutely terrified of Pat White is lieing to your face, as this guy is one of the deadliest players college football has seen in years. The defenses for both squads will have their work cut out stopping these two, and my prediction is that whichever one can have a bigger impact earlier on in the game will be the one that leads their team to victory. Forunately, the Panthers showed last season they can keep White in check after two years of flailing around hopelessly, but the Mounties had no answer for our superstar, Shady McCoy.
Panthers 20 Mountaineers 17

Sunday, November 9, 2008

The Weekend Review

For those of you who are legit Pittsburgh sports fans, the first 98% or so of the weekend went very, very well. The final 2% though was quite crushing.
Consider, these highlights, in chronological order:
-The Penguins started the weekend off a bit early by holding on for dear life with a 5-4 win over the Oilers where they jumped out in front 5 zip, then proceeded to soil themselves for the final 25 minutes of the game.
-The high school football playoffs for the WPIAL went into full swing Friday night with the quarterfinals, always an exciting team, regardless of what team you pull for.
-The Pitt Panthers got Saturday started off the right way, with a 41-7 drubbing of Louisville, cementing themselves as a serious contender for the Big East crown with just three games to go in the season. They also pretty much clinched their first bowl game in since 2004.
-The Penn State Nittany Lions dropped a heartbreaker to Iowa Saturday evening 24-23 on a last second field goal that warmed any Pitt fan's heart. (Sorry Nitter fans, if you are looking for a Pittsburgh site that also supports your squad, this sure as hell ain't it.)
-The West Virginia Mountaineers lost to Cincinnati in OT, continuing a season long underachieving run for the back woods bunch.
-The Pitt basketball team looked crisp in an exhibition win over LaRoche.
-The Steelers took a very tough loss just moments ago to the Colts, 24-20. I can't rationally discuss this one right now, so here's the rest of the highlights, with one mini-rant about the Steelers.

So, all in all, it was a simply spectacular weekend for yours truly, as my rivals lost, and my faves won. Just good times all around. Here are some assorted thoughts from the weekend:
-Pitt football heads into one of the most critical stretches its football program has seen in years, maybe even decades. Running the table would put them in the BCS, and while they did achieve that feat 4 years ago, it was in a very watered Big East, whereas the league nowadays is a very underrated and chippy conference.

-Jonathan Baldwin is an absolute beast and if Bill Stull knew how to throw a deep ball, this kid would be a Freshman All-American. He is going to be a legit special player when he becomes the focal point of the offense when Shady McCoy leaves after this season.

-Speaking of McCoy, he had a rough go of it against the Cardinals, as his numbers looked dreadful, but he still came through with two big runs (a touchdown run and a run to inside the 5 on another drive) and I think he'll rebound in a big way against Cincinnati.

-The Pens certainly like to keep their games interested don't they? Right now they look like they lack that killer instinct, and they certainly aren't putting teams away when they have the chance. I think this develops over time once they develop some better chemistry with their lines.

-I think one thing hardly anyone is mentioning is that this team really, really misses Sergei Gonchar, and doesn't miss Ryan Whitney at all. Gonch was a legit Norris candidate last season, and while he is best known for his offensive play from the point, he was a steadying force on defense, and put up the best blue line play I have ever seen out of a Penguin in my 15 or so years of watching this team. Whitney, on the other hand, looks more and more like a trade candidate when he comes back every day. Kris Letang and Alex Goligoski have stepped up and filled his role as offensive defensemen very well, and honestly I think Letang is already a better player then Whitney, at least the Whitney we saw at the end of last season. A year ago I thought the Whitney contract was a little on the large side, but worth it to lock up a future All-Star defender. Now, I think it's the one true mistake that Ray Shero has made in his tenure as General Manager.

-I can already sense the "Sidney Crosby is slumping" and "Is Malkin the real star of the Penguins?" articles that we know are coming if Sid continues to struggle to put points (especially goals) on the stat sheet. Look., folks, Sid started off a little on the slow side a year ago and still put up very good numbers before his injury, and I don't really know that he will be a 40 goal scorer type for a few more seasons, when he begins hitting his phyical peak. Still, he's scoring at a rate higher than most, and he scares the daylights out of opposing coaches. Sid will be fine, and will be a lot finer if Ray Shero can conjure a winger up for him at some point this season.

-I don't spend much time on Penn State and/or WVU on this site, as I loathe both schools quite a bit, but that was one real tough loss yesterday for the State Penn fans. Of course, in case you didn't know PSUers, the old P-I-T-T knocked off Iowa earlier this season. By a point. The same amount that Iowa beat you by. Care for a little lesson in comparison logic?

-The Steelers, prior to this week, have been ranked 3rd in virtually all 3.4 million power polls done worldwide, but frankly if that's true, then this is a really weak NFL season. This Steeler team would have been slaughtered by numerous past Steeler squads, and in the top heavy AFC of a few seasons ago, would have been hard pressed to make it to the post-season. I'll give the defense a ton of credit for being incredibly stifling and the absolute driving force. But the offense makes me a little bit queasy. Large Benjamin has been way too careless with the ball all season long. That offensive line is a disaster mixed with a catastrophe. The injury bug has hit them unbelievably hard considering its only mid season. They have had too many thin drafts the past few years and it is catching up to them on the depth chart. Hines Ward is firmly on the downhill slope of his career but is still our main weapon. Santonio Holmes continues to be unable to develop into the superstar receiver his talent would suggest he can be. Mewelde Moore is the only thing resembling an NFL running back on the healthy roster right now. This is really just a sampling of their problems, but they are the real reasons why, unless this team really develops over the next few weeks, I just can't pick them to be a Super Bowl contender right now. Of course, I would have said the same thing back in the 05/06 season as late as 12 games into it, and that season turned out pretty darn well, so you never know...

-I am all kinds of fired up for Pitt basketball this season. Our freshman look like they should all be more than ready to contribute this season, but having the veteran core should enable our brilliant coach Jamie Dixon to avoid having too heap too much pressure on them. I do think that one of the four freshman takes a redshirt, though, as I can't figure out how there will be enough minutes to go around for all of them otherwise, but we will see.